Britain shapes good citizens with a gentle ‘nudge’

Agence France Presse

Published — Saturday 2 February 2013

Last update 1 February 2013 9:46 pm

| نسخة PDF Print News | A A

It’s a riddle faced by cash-strapped governments the world over — how can people be persuaded to make decisions that leave them healthier and happier, while saving taxpayers’ money at the same time?
In Britain, Prime Minister David Cameron has set up a team to test out the theory that a gentle prod in the right direction can go a long way.
Nicknamed the “nudge unit,” the Behavioral Insights Team has been quietly reshaping a swath of policies to coax Britons into behaving — whether that means paying their taxes on time, saving energy or quitting smoking.
By tinkering here and adjusting there, the nudge unit claims that it will have saved Britain £300 million ($483 million, 361 million euros) over the next five years — taking even its director David Halpern by surprise.
“We’re steadily surprised by how well it works,” Halpern told AFP in an interview at Cameron’s Downing Street residence, where the 12-strong team has been based since its creation in 2010.
“There’s more demand than we can meet. We’ve had pretty much every government department coming to us saying, ‘Can you help us with this policy?’ — and we’re getting a lot of requests from other governments.”
The nudge unit’s favorite tactics involve making it easier for people to do what the government wants it to do — and, perhaps less obviously, telling people what their peers are doing. In one of its most successful examples, the team began sending letters to late taxpayers which casually mentioned that most people in their town had already paid.
This psychological trick boosted payments by 15 percent, adding £30 million to the government’s coffers in a year.
“We’re very social creatures. When you see other people doing things, you tend to do the same,” Halpern explained.
In another experiment, the team looked at how to encourage people to save energy by insulating their attics — something that 40 percent of homeowners have yet to do, despite years of government subsidy schemes.
Research revealed that for many Britons the main obstacle wasn’t the cost — it was that they used their attics to hoard junk they were too lazy to clear out.
“So we started offering a loft clearance scheme,” said Halpern. “Once we did that, we got a three-fold increase in uptake.”
Other governments are so interested in the nudge unit that it has begun selling its expertise abroad, helping Australia’s New South Wales state and another undisclosed government to set up their own.
Inspired by behavioral economists such as Richard Thaler and Cass Sunstein, the US duo who turned “nudge” into a political buzzword with their 2008 book of the same name, Cameron set up the unit immediately after coming to power almost three years ago.
He is not the only world leader to embrace the theory. Thaler has advised several governments including Denmark and France, while Sunstein held a senior post in US President Barack Obama’s administration until last August.
There are countless international examples of nudges. Famously, Schiphol Airport in the Netherlands dramatically cut spillages in its men’s toilets by etching fake insects into the urinals, giving passengers something to aim at.
But Britain has taken the idea a step further by setting up a government office dedicated to the art of nudging, a move Halpern said was heavily influenced by the feeble state of the British economy.
“When there’s no money around, these approaches start to look especially attractive,” he told AFP.
But the use of nudge theory by governments has been met with suspicion from some corners.
One Australian columnist described it as a “toxic import” that should not be welcomed by New South Wales.
“Instead of democratic debate and argument, it opts for subliminal psychological techniques and manipulation,” Frank Furedi argued in The Australian.
British critics have also suggested that that nudging is a sneaky form of state intervention — and one that does not sit easily with Cameron’s Conservative party, who often deride interference by the “nanny state.”
But the nudge unit denies that there is anything underhand about its techniques.
“Almost all policy is about understanding how people behave and trying to encourage them to behave differently,” argued Halpern’s deputy, Owain Service.
The nudge unit says it simply encourages people to make good decisions for themselves — and Halpern happily admits that this doesn’t always work.
In another loft insulation scheme, Britons were offered discounts if they clubbed together with their neighbors.
“People really liked the idea, but they didn’t actually have that conversation with their neighbors,” Halpern laughed. “It might work in a country other than the UK, where people talk to their neighbors a bit more.”

What's happening around Saudi Arabia

JEDDAH: It is the Islamic duty of all citizens to protect the security of their nation, according to Grand Mufti Sheikh Abdul Aziz Al-Asheikh.Al-Asheikh said that scholars and preachers are required by Islamic law to address problems facing society,...
RIYADH: Prince Sultan University students will launch an application on Dec. 9 for emergency medical services, which would link patients with ambulances.The app would allow people to share their locations, determine the time for an ambulance to arriv...
RIYADH: A man and a woman died in the past 24 hours in rain-related incidents as the capital was lashed by heavy rains. Four more patients also died in the central hospital due to respiratory problems due to the cold weather.Riyadh Civil Defense spok...
RIYADH: The King Salman Center for Relief and Humanitarian Works (KSCRHW) has started implementing a directive to distribute 200,000 lambs to Yemenis in the Hadramout province.“The aid came within an integrated program for the alleviation of the suff...
MADINAH: The Board of Forensics Medicine in Madinah has cleared a hospital here of negligence involving the death of a citizen at its facility, citing lack of evidence and that the defendants, two consultants, failed to turn up for the hearing.The fa...
JEDDAH: A young Saudi man has won an international innovation award for inventing a “smart boat” that can monitor sea pollution.Abdulaziz bin Mashhoor Al-Shammakhi won the award with 20 young people who were selected from among 700 participants from...
JEDDAH: Umrah pilgrims can expect to save between 10 and 15 percent on the cost of their hotels under a new electronic booking system that cuts out intermediaries.This is according to Abdullah Qadi, deputy president of the national committee for Haj...
RIYADH: Surgery performed at King Khalid Hospital in Najran made a 40-year-old Saudi woman regain her sight which was lost eight months ago.Hospital General Supervisor Abdo Al-Zobayri said here that the patient had lost her sight eight months ago bec...
RIYADH: More than 200,000 women were tested for breast cancer and only 15 positive cases were detected in the capital during the monthlong campaign to fight breast cancer which ended here on Tuesday.Speaking at the closing ceremony of the campaign, D...
KUWAIT: Kuwaiti Minister of Commerce and Industry Yusuf Al-Ali issued a decree to ban the import of all types of livestock including cows, goats, sheep, giraffes, camels, lamas, antelopes, and others from markets including Saudi Arabia, France and Sl...
RIYADH: Health Awareness of Our Society (Hayatuna) Secretary General Dr. Abdulrahman Al-Qahtani has urged drivers to stop at a safe place if they have to call or answer their cell phones.“If a motorist wants to use his cell phone while driving or wan...
RIYADH: The Kingdom has recorded remarkable growth in the volume of expenditure for domestic tourism this year which has increased to SR42.2 billion as against SR35.4 billion last year, according to the Tourism Information and Research Center (MAS),...
JEDDAH: Pakistan Navy warship PNS Tariq has arrived at Jeddah Islamic Port on a goodwill and training visit. The ship, which arrived on Monday and is under the command of Capt. Syed Asad Ali Imran, had come from the Gulf of Aden after taking part in...
JEDDAH: The new Sri Lankan ambassador to Saudi Arabia has stressed the importance of improving the island nation’s relationship with Saudi Arabia.Ambassador Azmi Thassim was speaking during his recent visit to the Sri Lankan International School in J...
JEDDAH: A former member of the Commission for the Promotion of Virtue and Prevention of Vice (Haia), announced that he withdrew the lawsuit he had previously filed against a young man who assaulted him with a knife on the night of Eid Al-Fitr in 1434...

Events & Exhibitions

Stay Connected