Israeli says Facebook photo with Arabs thoughtless

Eden Abergil poses for a photograph near Palestinian detainees in this picture taken in 2008, as seen from this screen shot of the Sachim Tumblr blog taken August 17, 2010. The former Israeli soldier said on Tuesday she saw nothing wrong in having posted the pictures of herself on Facebook posing next to handcuffed and blindfolded Palestinian detainees. (Reuters)

By AISHA MOHAMMED | AP

JERUSALEM: A former Israeli soldier who posted photos on Facebook of herself in uniform smiling beside bound and blindfolded Palestinian prisoners said her actions were "thoughtless," but she stopped short of apologizing.

Both the Israeli army and Palestinian officials condemned the young woman, Eden Aberjil, over the photographs — one of which was accompanied by an exchange with a friend including jokes and sexual innuendoes.

Aberjil called her decision to post the photos, taken in 2008 near the Gaza Strip, "thoughtless and innocent." But she added: "I still don't understand what wasn't OK."

"There was no statement in the photos about violence, about disrespect, about anything that would hurt that person. I just had my picture taken with someone in the background," she told Israel's Army Radio. However, "when I understood that so many people were hurt by those pictures, I removed them."

In a separate interview, Aberjil lashed out at the international uproar over the pictures, which were reminders of the snapshots taken in 2003 by American soldiers at an Iraqi prison showing Iraqi detainees, humiliated and terrified. However, the Israeli pictures showed no signs of physical abuse or coercion.

"I did not humiliate those detainees. I didn't hit them, I didn't act toward them unpleasantly. It's completely different than the American soldier some are trying to compare me to," she told Israel Radio.

She said she was shocked by the international interest in the story, and claimed that things like this happen "every day" in the Israeli army.

Palestinians are routinely handcuffed and blindfolded when they are arrested to stop them from trying to flee.

One photo showed Aberjil sitting beside a blindfolded Palestinian man slumped against a concrete barrier, while she leans toward him with her face upturned. Another shows her smiling at the camera with three blindfolded Palestinian men behind her.

The photos, taken in 2008 near the Gaza Strip, drew sharp criticism from the Israeli military, pro-Palestinian advocacy groups and Palestinian officials.

Yehuda Shaul of Breaking the Silence, a group of former Israeli combat officers that criticizes Israeli policies toward the Palestinians, said the pictures showed how Israel's occupation of Palestinian areas has become "so routine ... you lose the ability to see them as human beings."

Capt. Barak Raz, an Israeli military spokesman, said the pictures amount to "a serious violation of our morals and our ethical code."

Although her former commanders have been informed of the pictures, it is not clear whether the army can punish Aberjil because she has finished her compulsory military service.

Comments

OM

Report abuse
This Israeli woman should be ashamed of herself! She should have the decency to apologize for posting those photos. How would she feel if she were the one blindfolded, handcuffed and photographed like that?!

TOMM

Report abuse
I notice Abu Gharaib keeps coming up. FYI US military prisoners are to be photographed for only for official purposes of record keeping and identification. And, that means, that all the photos that you saw on line were in violated of an American military codes. Prisoners are not to be deliberately demeaned either. They will be treated at dangerous adversities and restricted as such, to include blindfolds, cuffs, leg shackles and hearing protectors (so they don’t hear). This Israeli is being photographed with them as if they were trophies and that is wrong

YASSER

Report abuse
The day will come when Palestine will be liberated and this soldier and her colleagues will be the ones tied up and blindfolded and photographed before being shipped back to Europe and the US where they came from.

SAFOORA

Report abuse
How is this in any way ok? Why isnt there a bigger outrage?????

MUSHTAQ N. SHAH

Report abuse
This young lady officer is not at fault. The "Jewish" establishment is. The only blood curdling reality is that one day when the tables turn I wonder what the Muslims will make out of these arrogant Jewish people. After all history is replete with such changes over centuries if not days. Till then best of luck to the arrogant "racist" nation of "Israel".
Post your comment

required

required (email will never be displayed)

Please enter the following characters in the box provided (case sensitive). This helps us prevent automated programs from creating accounts and sending spam.

All comments are subject to approval

Terms and conditions

Latest comments