Renault may block Nissan reform over boardroom dispute

Renault Chairman Jean-Dominique Senard reportedly plans for the French carmaker to abstain in a shareholder vote on Nissan’s reorganization. (Reuters)
Updated 10 June 2019
0

Renault may block Nissan reform over boardroom dispute

  • Renault owns 43.4 percent of alliance partner Nissan
  • There is concern about Renault’s under-representation on the new Nissan board committees being introduced

PARIS: Renault has signaled it will block reforms launched by alliance partner Nissan in the wake of the Carlos Ghosn scandal unless it is granted representation on new board committees, a source close to the French carmaker said.
Renault, which owns 43.4 percent of Nissan, informed its Japanese affiliate in a letter signed by Chairman Jean-Dominique Senard that it planned to abstain in a shareholder vote on the plans, the Financial Times reported earlier on Sunday.
An abstention by Renault would effectively block the reforms, which require a two-thirds majority to pass.
A Renault spokeswoman did not immediately return calls and messages seeking comment.
Japan’s Jiji news agency quoted Nissan Chief Executive Hiroto Saikawa as saying: “We are preparing for the shareholder meeting and will discuss necessary issues at the appropriate time. If there are differences of opinion (with Renault), then I’d like for those to be discussed.”
The source said Senard’s letter was motivated by concern about Renault’s under-representation on the new Nissan board committees being introduced following the November arrest of their former chairman Carlos Ghosn, who is now awaiting trial in Japan on financial misconduct charges he denies.
“It’s is not a final abstention, and Renault’s position can still change,” the Renault source said. “As things stand, Renault has not been assured of appropriate committee representation as Nissan’s main shareholder.”


Nissan post-Ghosn governance steps, board win shareholders’ approval

Updated 5 min 32 sec ago
0

Nissan post-Ghosn governance steps, board win shareholders’ approval

  • The Japanese automaker had seen profits and dividends tumble amid a high-profile scandal involving its former chairman Carlos Ghosn
  • Some shareholders expressed worries about the future of the automaker

YOKOHAMA, Japan: Scandal-battered Nissan won shareholders’ approval Tuesday for a new system of committees to oversee governance and for keeping Chief Executive Hiroto Saikawa on its board.
The Japanese automaker had seen profits and dividends tumble amid a high-profile scandal involving its former chairman Carlos Ghosn. Some shareholders expressed worries about the future of the automaker.
Saikawa and the other board members, including French alliance partner Renault Chairman Jean-Dominique Senard, bowed deeply at the meeting at a convention center in the port city of Yokohama, where Nissan Motor Corp. is based.
“I’d like to offer my deepest apologies, representing the company, for how the misconduct has caused serious concern for our shareholders,” Saikawa said.
Ghosn, who led Nissan for two decades, was arrested in November and is awaiting trial in Japan on charges of financial misconduct, including falsifying documents related to retirement compensation. He says he is innocent.
The proposals to have committees overseeing compensation, board nominations and auditing required a majority of shareholders for a quorum and two-thirds of those voting for passage.
Approval was shown by clapping among the more than 2,800 people present at the meeting. Most of the votes were submitted in advance.
French automaker Renault, which owns 43 percent of Nissan, had earlier signaled it may abstain, saying it wanted more representation on the committees.
To satisfy that request, the committees have Senard, who replaced Ghosn on the Nissan board, and Renault Chief Executive Thierry Bollore.
Saikawa told shareholders he had “two kinds of responsibility,” for what had happened in the past as well as building toward a future and a recovery, including nurturing his successor.
“I would like to work toward putting Nissan on a stable track,” he said, asking for shareholders’ approval for his remaining as Nissan’s leader. “I want to speed up the preparations for a succession.”
Although Nissan has been trying to put the scandal behind it, many have been wondering why the alleged wrongdoing, if true, had gone unchecked, especially how much Saikawa knew. One shareholder asked whether Nissan officials besides Ghosn shared in the alleged misconduct.
For the fiscal year that ended in March, Nissan’s profit plunged to about half of what it was the previous year, partly because of the scandal, as well as problems in the lucrative North American market. The maker of the Leaf electric car and Infiniti luxury models is projecting a further deterioration in its earnings, but promising a recovery for the year after that.
It logged $83 million (¥9.2 billion) in costs for the fiscal year that ended in March from alleged underreporting of Ghosn’s compensation.
The proposal, which won shareholders’ approval, called for an 11-member board, including seven outside directors such as Andrew House, formerly with Japanese electronics and entertainment company Sony Corp.
For the appointment of directors, a third of the shareholders made for a quorum, and passage needed a simple majority of those voting.
Some analysts suggest a deepening rift between Renault and Nissan after a planned merger between Renault and Fiat Chrysler fell through earlier this month. Nissan expressed reservations about immediately joining the merger.
Some shareholders expressed worries about the alliance, and one who stood up to ask a question said the main person who had made decisions, referring to Ghosn, was now gone.
Nissan held an extraordinary shareholders’ meeting in April to oust Ghosn. Last week, Mitsubishi Motors Corp., a smaller Japanese automaker in which Nissan owns a 34 percent stake, won shareholders’ approval to oust Ghosn.