Fatwa seeking death for gender mixing shocks society

By WALAA HAWARI | ARAB NEWS

RIYADH: A Saudi cleric has shocked the international and Saudi communities after he issued a fatwa last Tuesday calling for those who promote co-educational environments to be put to death.

Sheikh Abdul Rahman Al-Barrak said the mixing of men and women in the workplace or educational institutions was religiously prohibited.

“Whoever allows this mixing allows forbidden things, and whoever allows them is an infidel and this means defection from Islam. Either he retracts or he must be killed because he disavows and does not observe the Shariah,” he said.

Al-Barrak’s claims his fatwa is based on grounds that ikhtilat, or the mixing of men and women, allows for the possibility of seeing what must not be seen and engaging in forbidden conversations.

Born in Qassim, 77-year-old Al-Barrak is known for issuing a number of controversial fatwas in the past.

In March 2008 he denounced two Saudi writers for articles that he claimed conflicted with Shariah teachings. He called for their prosecution on charges of apostasy — abandoning their religious beliefs — adding that if they did not retract their statements they should be put to death.

The subject of ikhtilat and its interpretation has become an issue of public controversy recently, especially as religious officials are considering allowing it.

Yet Sheikh Sa’ad Al-Shethri, a member of the Board of Senior Ulema, was removed from his post last year after criticizing the King Abdullah University of Science and Technology (KAUST) for promoting a co-education environment. Several senior scholars from the Kingdom and abroad spoke out in support of KAUST. Sheikh Ahmad Al-Ghamdi, head of the Commission for Promotion of Virtue and Prevention of Vice in Makkah and the Minister of Justice Muhammed Al-Eissa were among them.

Kuwaiti scholars claimed that such an edict could come only from a senile person or someone who wants to sow sedition in the nation by allowing the killing of innocent people.

Leading Kuwaiti scholar Sheikh Ahmad Hussain blasted the fatwa, saying that Islam was very strict about killing people intentionally.

“Officials need to step in promptly and make the authors of such edicts face legal measures to ensure no innocent people are killed or harmed by those who want to implement the fatwas,” said Dr. Ajeel Al-Nashmi, head of the GCC Religious Scholars League.

Dr. Abdul Moti Baiomi, a former deputy of the Religious Affairs Committee at the Egyptian Parliament who is also a member of the Islamic Research Center at Al-Azhar, criticized Al-Barrak.

“What Al-Barrak said is far from accurate, as it is a rigid opinion that deviates from Islam’s teachings,” Baiomi told Kol Al-Watan online, clarifying that ikhtilat is permitted as long as it is within the realms of decency and respect, especially in classrooms and workplaces.

Bloggers also expressed fears the fatwa that could lead to the deaths of innocent people.

Ahmad Al-Omranm, who blogs for Saudi Jeans, believes that failure to address Al-Barrak’s fatwa could have serious consequences.

“What if one of his enthusiastic fans decides to act upon this fatwa and kill somebody?”

Kuwaiti scholar Shaikh Ahmad Hussain said, “All the Qura’nic teachings and the Prophet’s (peace be upon him) Sayings stress that killing is not allowed. God said that if you kill a believer, it is like you have killed all people.”

Comments

ZEESHAN HANIF

Report abuse
Salaamualikum, The tone of this fatwa is pure agression & anger......is this what Islam teaches? What will a non-muslim think of this fatwa assuming he had no knowledge of Islam. "...and whoever allows them is an infidel". Calling a Muslim an Infidel is Haraam. I was brought up in a mixed school in Jeddah and as a muslim I know my limits.....so am I an infidel? Muslims are required the following: 1. Treat one another with respect at all times in all situations. 2. Behave modestly. 3. Avoid situations of seclusion (khalwa). 4. Dress modestly (by covering ones body).

MISS

Report abuse
whatever happened to the 10 commandments dat God has given to the prophet musa...thou shall not kill...???

WASEEM

Report abuse
Any Fatwa that calls for killing of a perpratrator of crimes that affect the society is not for individuals. This if for the Judiciary & Courts. The case will be referred to the Courts who will then decide if the alleged crime necessitates incarceration or a death penalty which is only executed if all the avenues of correction of the individual have been exhausted & he refuses to desist from his devaint ways. I hope this is well understood by the authors who write publicly & qouted by them so as not to mislead the readers.

DAVE

Report abuse
What is happening is reprehensible and i believe shocking to most Saudis. The coed system is followed in rest of the world including neighboring states like Bahrain and Qatar without any so called problem to the society. This fatwa must be recalled and legal measures taken to ensure this does not happen again in the future.

ABDULLAH AL ALAMI

Report abuse
I call upon the government to restrain people like these. This is a typical example of "Shaikhs" feeding hatred, violence and terrorism.
Post your comment

required

required (email will never be displayed)

Please enter the following characters in the box provided (case sensitive). This helps us prevent automated programs from creating accounts and sending spam.

All comments are subject to approval

Terms and conditions

Latest comments