US needs rethink of Mideast peace plan, say experts



AGENCE FRANCE PRESSE

Published — Wednesday 28 November 2012

Last update 27 November 2012 11:24 pm

| نسخة PDF Print News | A A

WASHINGTON: The US administration must radically rethink ways to achieve a sustainable Israeli-Arab peace deal or risk seeing the goal of a two-state solution slip away, experts warned Monday.
New realities in the Middle East, including the changes wrought by the Arab Spring and the rise of the Palestinian group Hamas, meant the old ways of doing business had to be shelved, they told a Washington symposium.
“If we don’t seize whatever opportunity there is in the present, the prospects for negotiating a solution anytime in the near future are really very slim,” said William Quandt, who as a member of the National Security Council was deeply involved in reaching the historic 1978 Camp David accords.
“Maybe it’s already too late, I don’t think we will ever know unless we give it a serious try,” he added, arguing it was ultimately in the US security interest to secure a peace deal.
Direct peace talks between Israel and the Palestinians, initiated by President Barack Obama, have stalled since late 2010, and there has been a perceived lack of appetite for a renewed US engagement in the region.
But the recent war in Gaza was “a microcosm of the tectonic shifts that President Obama is going to have to confront,” warned Robert Malley from the International Crisis Group.
The three traditional pillars for peacemaking — strong Israeli-Palestinian entities, Arab nations ready to help the US and pressure the Palestinians, and a credible United States — “have all eroded,” Malley said.
Therefore, America’s way of looking at the decades-old conflict had to change, argued Malley, program director at the ICG.
“Just as you can’t wage yesterday’s war, you can’t wage yesterday’s peace... We have to rethink the solution that we all thought we knew,” he said, speaking at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace to mark the launch of a new book “Pathways to Peace.” A series of top experts writing in the book have suggested ways for Obama to embark on a serious effort in his second term to bring together the Israelis and Palestinians.
Former Jordanian Foreign Minister Marwan Muasher agreed Obama’s task lay between the “difficult and the impossible,” concerned that both a two-state solution and the Arab peace initiative, which he helped launch, were dying.
Obama must engage the Middle East region almost immediately after being inaugurated in January, he argued.
Behind-the-scenes talks should seek to secure what Muasher called “endgame deposits” — a clear idea of each side’s final position on some of the core issues still to be resolved, including the return of Palestinian refugees.
It was also vital to start setting the contours of the two states, said Daniel Kurtzer, former US ambassador to both Israel and Egypt, and now Princeton professor, who edited the book.
“Until we know where the state of Israel is and isn’t, until we know where the state of Palestine is or isn’t, everything else becomes commentary,” he said, adding that extensive work had already been done on the issue.
Obama had “got it right,” Kurtzer noted, when he said that discussions should start at the point of the 1967 borders, knowing that as the negotiations proceed these will change with mutually-agreed upon land swaps.
America must also be prepared to engage with Hamas, currently considered a terrorist group by the United States, which maintains ties with the Fatah group of Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas.
Quandt looked back to the days when the United States had to negotiate with the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO). “Now everybody looks at Fatah and the PLO as model citizens... We had to start talking to them when they were anything but model citizens.” “It really doesn’t make sense for us to put our heads in the sand and pretend that Fatah is what it once was,” agreed Malley.
“That it has the ability to generate popular support like it once did, and that Hamas is as marginalized as it may have been in the 1990s. None of that holds any more.” It was also vitally important for Obama to “find your team,” argued analyst Aaron David Miller, and for him to empower his next secretary of state as Hillary Clinton prepares to step down.
Miller, now vice president for new initiatives at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars, spent two decades at the State Department formulating US policy on the Middle East.
What was needed, he said, was a “conflict-ending agreement” which resolved all the outstanding core issues and allowed each side to say “we may never love you, but our business with you is done.” However, “I do not see with my eyes... the prospects of that kind of agreement materializing any time soon,” he warned, adding the two sides currently existed in a kind of twilight zone between peace and confrontation.
“In my view the pursuit of a two-state solution right now is too complicated to succeed, but too important, resonant and relevant still to fail.”

What's happening around Saudi Arabia

JEDDAH: Two members of a Ministry of Health ambulance crew, including a doctor, were killed when their vehicle overturned along a highway in Madinah region on Tuesday, an online site reported.The driver also died and a nurse suffered injuries, 3alyou...
RIYADH: Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques King Salman briefed the Cabinet, on Monday, about the message he sent to the Kuwaiti emir and the messages he received from the Moroccan king and the Qatari emir.The king also spoke about the outcome of his m...
RIYADH: The Eastern Mediterranean Office (EMRO) of the World Health Organization (WHO) on Monday announced that the region is considered a Zika virus-free zone.Dr. Alaa Alwan, the regional director of EMRO, said that it does not mean that Middle East...
JEDDAH: The Saudi Health Council is working to establish an electronic system to prevent manipulation of sick leave holidays.Dr. Yaqoob Al-Mazrouh, secretary-general of the council, disclosed this during a seminar on Sunday. He did not elaborate on h...
RIYADH: Specialized Clinics Arabia (SCA) treated a total of 9,220 Syrians at the Zaatari Refugee Camp in Jordan during the month of January 2016, according to Dr. Hamid Mufalana, SCA medical director.“Many of the patients were children who were given...
JEDDAH: The Jeddah police have solved the mystery surrounding the thrashing of a man by another, the video clip of which had gone viral.It was a Herculean task for the police to search for the victim, who had not bothered to lodge any complaint. The...
JEDDAH: The Cutoms Department at Yanbu’s Prince Abdul Mohsen bin Abdul Aziz Airport recently foiled an attempt to smuggle 64,165 Captagon pills found hidden in four boxes.Saad Al-Buqami, director-general of Customs at the Airport, said: “During our c...
AL-AHSA: Plans are afoot to turn the Al-Ahsa dates festival into an international event by adopting top standards in the manufacture, packaging and marketing of the product, Adel Al-Mulhim, the general supervisor of the festival, has said.Speaking du...
RIYADH: A gang comprising two women and youth has been arrested for allegedly looting cash from pharmacies and snatching women’s handbags in malls.Col. Fawaz bin Jameel Al-Maiman, police media spokesman of the Riyadh region, said the arrests were mad...
RIYADH: Riyadh Gov. Prince Faisal bin Bandar on Sunday called for conservation of water and electricity, even as the Water and Electricity minister said Saudi Arabia will need an investment of SR500 billion for power projects over the next 10 years t...
RIYADH: More than 200,000 people accused of various crimes were investigated by the Bureau of Investigation and Public Prosecution (BIPP) in the financial year of 1435-1436 A.H.Among the 218,000 who were investigated, around 30 percent or 65,000 were...
RIYADH: Thousands of Saudis have visited the German pavilion at the Janadriyah festival since it was opened by Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques King Salman last week, in the presence of German Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier and German Amba...
DAMMAM: The cold wave in many parts of the Kingdom over the last week caused a decline of between 30 percent and 50 percent in farm production. This decline in turn drove prices of agricultural products at wholesale markets up by 30 percent.Farmers s...
RIYADH: The Ministry of Commerce and Industry warned on Monday that heating devices should have a voltage of 220 volts with a capacity not exceeding 2,500 watts.The announcement was made when MCI inspectors seized more than 3,000 substandard heating...
ALKHOBAR: Nearly 100 leading figures in the government and private institutions have completed training programs specializing in integrity and anti-corruption provided by the Saafah Foundation for Good Example in Riyadh, Jeddah and Alkhobar.The secre...

Stay Connected

Facebook