US immigration bill splits Republicans


Published — Saturday 2 February 2013

Last update 3 February 2013 2:01 am

| نسخة PDF Print News | A A

WASHINGTON: The immigration debate is threatening to split the Republican Party, pitting those who focus mainly on presidential elections against those who care mostly about congressional races.
Strategists say that if Republicans are to win presidential elections, which they’ve been losing lately, partly because of dismal support from Hispanic voters, they must soften their rhetoric about illegal immigrants and embrace some version of “immigration reform.”
But granting illegal residents a pathway to citizenship, which critics call “amnesty,” is deeply unpopular in many House Republicans’ districts.
President Barack Obama wants such a pathway. So do some prominent Republican lawmakers who are seeking a way out of their party’s jam.
The plans differ on when and how citizenship might occur, with border security a central issue. Resolving these differences may determine whether a major law is enacted in the coming months.
Some Republican strategists fear they will lose either way.
If by the next election Latino voters think Republicans opposed and possibly blocked a comprehensive immigration overhaul, they might turn against the party in even bigger numbers.
On the other hand, converting millions of illegal Hispanic residents into citizens might produce large numbers of new voters who will lean Democratic for years.
“This is a perilous debate that Republicans have entered into,” John Ullyot, a Republican consultant and a former Senate aide, said.
Obama won 71 percent of the Hispanic vote last November and 67 percent in 2008. Republican campaign professionals say Republicans are dooming themselves if they don’t show a more welcoming face to this fast-growing segment of voters.
“Republicans need to solve this issue, politically, if they wish to win national elections, and they know it,” said Texas-based Republican consultant Matt Mackowiak.
Winning elections to the House of Representatives, however, is a different matter.
A number of Republican lawmakers and aides say “amnesty” for illegal immigrants triggers strong resentment among their constituents. The upcoming debates could stir passions further, even in swing districts.
Rep. Steve Chabot lost his Cincinnati-area seat in Ohio to a Democrat in 2008, then regained it two years later. He opposes giving illegal immigrants an eventual route to citizenship.
“It is unfair to allow those who have willfully and intentionally broken our nation’s immigration laws to, in essence, cut in front of those who have been patiently and legally waiting their turn to become US citizens,” Chabot wrote on his House blog. Republicans should appeal to Hispanic voters “on principle,” he said, not by agreeing to liberal immigration policies. “Republicans are better for Hispanics because our policies are better for them,” Chabot said.
Republican leaders hope to minimize internal conflicts by finding a compromise that Obama and the Democratic-controlled Senate will accept.
A bipartisan group of senators has proposed a plan that would allow illegal immigrants to pursue citizenship only after steps, yet to be detailed, are taken to further secure the border with Mexico. The plan is backed by Republican Sen. Marco Rubio of Florida, whose parents were born in Cuba. He is seen as leading player on immigration.
Some other high-profile conservatives, including Fox News commentator Sean Hannity and the 2012 Republican vice presidential nominee, Wisconsin Rep. Paul Ryan, have spoken favorably about Rubio’s approach.
Democrats insist that the border security prerequisites not be onerous. They worry that Republicans will never agree that border enforcement is strong enough to start the citizenship process for illegals. Similarly, some Republicans say they fear Democrats won’t deliver tougher security once illegal immigrants are allowed the first step toward legal status.
Republican strategists say respectful rhetoric in the coming debates is crucial to wooing Hispanic voters who feel previous Republican comments revealed anti-immigrant feelings.
“If the tone of the debate is thoughtful,” then Republicans can survive politically even if they reject “blanket amnesty,” campaign adviser Terry Nelson said.
Rep. Greg Walden of Oregon, who heads the Republican Party’s 2014 House campaign efforts, said the party must communicate better with minorities.
“Obviously we’ve got to address this,” he said of immigration changes. “We’ve got 50,000 young Hispanics reaching voter age every month.”
Some conservative pundits, however, say turning illegal immigrants into voting citizens will hurt the Republican Party, not help it.
Latinos “are disproportionately low-income and disproportionately likely to receive some form of government support,” the conservative magazine National Review said in an editorial. “Take away the Spanish surname and Latino voters look a great deal like many other Democratic constituencies.”
House Speaker John Boehner says he’s ready to tackle big changes in immigration laws. But the effort may conflict with another of his goals: passing major legislation only if most House Republicans support it.
House insiders say many, and perhaps most, Republican lawmakers will want to vote against a citizenship-granting immigration bill, even if they quietly hope it passes and helps their party at the presidential level.
Such “vote no, hope yes” groups are well-suited for passing difficult measures with a modest number of Republican votes and many Democratic votes. It happened twice in January: on a hurricane aid bill and a vote to avert the “fiscal cliff” of automatically triggered tax increases and spending cuts.
At a recent House Republican retreat in Virginia, Boehner brought in independent political analyst Charlie Cook to explain to lawmakers why they face serious trouble with Hispanic voters.
Cook said House Republicans make a mistake if they view national issues such as immigration “through the prism of your district,” said a participant at the private session. Republicans eventually can improve their standing with Latinos if they stop talking and acting as though they don’t like immigrants, Cook told the House members.
“Holes tend to fill in over time if people stop digging,” Cook was quoted as telling the lawmakers.

What's happening around Saudi Arabia

KADUNA, Nigeria: Three years after his family fled their northeastern Nigerian home to escape threats from Boko Haram militants, Mudasir Gambo must have thought his luck had changed when he won a ticket to perform Haj.But in a cruel twist of fate, t...
RIYADH: Indian and international media has published an erroneous story of a 55-year-old Indian housemaid in the Kingdom who, it said, lost her right hand in amputation surgery as a result of torture by her Saudi female boss.First Secretary (Communit...
RIYADH: Thirty-three percent of 1,252 coronavirus cases reported over the past four years took place within hospitals.According to statistics, 413 cases emerged inside hospitals, while 12 percent of total cases involved health workers inside hospital...
RIYADH: The forensic board in Riyadh has issued orders against 194 people who committed medical mistakes last year. Among them are 165 Saudi doctors and 29 non-Saudi doctors, according to an online newspaper.Among those who have been punished for med...
JEDDAH: Talented American student of Sudanese origin Ahmed Mohammed Al-Hassan arrived in Jeddah on Friday morning to perform Umrah and visit his relatives. The Kingdom last week invited Al-Hassan to visit the country for Umrah. On his arrival at King...
RIYADH: Abdul Moneim Al-Mushawwah, the director of the Sakina Campaign, which operates under the supervision of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs, revealed what he called a fierce electronic campaign against the Kingdom led by Iran.Al-Mushawwah said th...
JEDDAH: A local college has signed an agreement with a bank to provide loans for students to complete their studies.The agreement was signed between Najwa Salem, executive director of Batterjee Education and Training Academy (BETA) and Turki Al-Juhan...
RIYADH: A new weekly program entitled “Yemen After the Storm” will begin Monday at 9 p.m. on Tabah Saudi television to be aired from Madinah and will last for 30 weeks.“The program will be a medium for Yemenis and Saudis to extend their gratitude to...
MAKKAH: The Makkah municipality will build the first footbridge in the Sharaie area in east Makkah at a cost of SR5.358 million. The municipality has announced the location to the implementing company, who will begin work at the beginning of next mon...
DAMMAM: Approximately 800 male and female participants gathered along the waterfront at Dammam Corniche recently to take part in a 60 minute walking tour on the occasion of the World Walking Day, which coincided with World Heart Day.According to stat...
RIYADH: The number of vacant positions in government jobs has reached 319,474 which is 20.5 percent of total government jobs. Most of these vacant positions are in the health and education sector, an online newspaper reported, citing an unnamed sourc...
JEDDAH: A smartphone is a modern day distraction as it is taken everywhere, demanding attention multiple times a day. Whether it’s a phone call, a snapchat story, a Facebook and Instagram notification or someone retweeting your tweets.A Saudi husband...
Police said a young Saudi woman in Tabuk was found covered in blood after she tried to commit suicide recently by cutting her wrist.The authorities said that the woman was found alive inside the toilet of a well-known mall after the information was...
JEDDAH: The Jeddah Chamber of Commerce and Industry (JCCI) is linking up with various companies and the National Organization for Joint Training (NOJT) to offer 1,035 jobs in 59 sectors to Saudis at a career fair here on Oct. 13 and 14.Mohiuddin Hakm...
RIYADH: The Riyadh police department arrested 240 people for violating the country’s labor laws at markets and in various neighborhoods this week.The raids, which took place in cooperation with the Labor Ministry, saw 60 people arrested Thursday for...

Stay Connected