Apple fined $ 165,908 in copyright case

BEIJING: Technology giant Apple has been ordered to pay compensation to eight Chinese writers and two companies for selling unlicensed books online, state media reported.
The California-based company was ordered to pay a total fine of 1.03 million yuan ($ 165,908) to the plaintiffs for violating their copyrights, Xinhua news agency said.
The ruling was issued by the Beijing No. 2 Intermediate People’s Court, the report said.
Xinhua quoted a lawyer for the plaintiffs as saying they had seen applications that contained unlicensed electronic versions of their books available for download last year.
The downloads, which were described as being in great quantity and resulted in large economic losses for the plaintiffs, the lawyer was quoted as saying.
According to Xinhua, the court decided that the plaintiffs’ “right of communication through information networks” covered by China’s Copyright Law had been violated by Apple through its provision of apps that included the unlicensed books.
“As an IP holder ourselves, we understand the importance of protecting intellectual property and take copyright infringement complaints very seriously,” Apple spokeswoman Carolyn Wu said.
“We’re always updating our service to better assist content owners in protecting their rights.”
Wu said the company’s App Store provides customers in China with a selection of more than 700,000 apps created by the company’s developer community.
Reuters earlier reported that Apple CEO Tim Cook’s 2012 compensation package of $ 4.17 million is a huge cut on paper for the top executive of the most valuable US corporation, after a 2011 package fattened by more than $ 376 million in long-term stock awards.
Cook received the largest single pay package awarded to a company CEO in about a decade when he replaced Apple co-founder Steve Jobs in August last year, shortly before the Silicon Valley legend’s death in October 2011.
The maker of the iPhone and iPad made the 2012 compensation disclosures in a regulatory filing. Cook, 52, has been with Apple since 1998.
Virtually all of Cook’s $ 376 million stock bonus in 2011 was in awards that vest in two chunks — one in 2016 and the other in 2021. This structure was intended to keep Jobs’ longtime lieutenant at the helm for many years, as the value of the stock will depend on how well the company is doing in 2016 and 2021.
Cook, who is credited with masterminding a sprawling but efficient Asian supply chain, has generally received high marks for his first year for shepherding several successful gadget launches, including the iPhone 5.
But he was forced to make a public apology in September after the company launched a mapping service application riddled with glaring geographical errors. The Maps app fiasco contributed to the departure of fellow Apple veteran and software chief Scott Forstall.
In addition, some analysts questioned whether Cook, whose only major new product since taking the helm was a smaller version of the iPad that Jobs propelled into the mainstream in 2010, has the vision to produce the next big product category and sustain historically stellar growth for Apple as global mobile competition intensifies.
“The jury is still out in terms of the job he is doing,” said fund manager Tim Ghriskey, whose Solaris Group counts Apple stock as the biggest holding among the approximately $ 2 billion it manages.
But he said the company’s long-term prospects look strong, particularly if it rolls out oft-rumored television products in the next few years.
As of Thursday’s close, Apple shares were almost 37 percent higher than when Cook became CEO 16 months ago. However, since a record-high close of $ 702.10 on Sept. 19, the stock has fallen almost 27 percent.
Ghriskey said Wall Street remained nervous about the growing popularity of Google Inc’s Android phone software, used by global smartphone leader Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd, and potential margin pressure from that intensifying competition.
In terms of base salary, Cook actually received a 50 percent increase to $ 1.4 million for 2012, and the same 200 percent non-equity bonus other top Apple executives like CFO Peter Oppenheimer earned, Apple said in the Thursday filing ahead of a Feb. 27 shareholders’ meeting.
Cook’s 2012 package includes a nonequity bonus of $ 2.8 million.
Despite the increase, Apple said Cook’s target annual cash compensation is “significantly below the median annual cash compensation level for CEOs at peer companies.”
It also said that Cook will not receive any stock awards for 2012.
Cook’s latest compensation package also pales in comparison to his package in 2010, when he was chief operating officer. That package was 14 times higher.
A company spokesman would not comment beyond the filing.
Jobs famously received $1 a year in salary in the three years before he stepped down, though in 2000 he too received a stock option that analysts say was valued at almost $ 600 million at the time.
Looking beyond Apple, Yahoo Inc’s Marissa Mayer, a former Google Inc. high-flyer hired this year to try to turn around the struggling Internet icon, won a pay package worth more than $ 70 million. Despite her lack of a track record as CEO and Yahoo’s tiny size in comparison, her basic pay is comparable to Cook’s, with about $1 million in annual salary and up to $ 2 million in an annual bonus.
Oracle Corp’s Larry Ellison, one of the most highly paid US chief executives — and also the world’s sixth-richest man, according to Forbes — received total compensation for the year ended May 31, 2012, of $ 96.2 million — almost all of it in stock options. That compared with $ 77.6 million in 2011.
According to a study of the Fortune 500 conducted by Forbes this year, CEOs were paid a base salary of $ 1.1 million in 2011 on average, with the mean annual bonus at $ 2.4 million and average total compensation — including stock awards — at around $17 million.