Pakistan finance minister steps down amid IMF talks, budget preparations

1 / 2
Speculation has been rife in recent days that Umar would be replaced, mostly over delays in reaching a bailout deal with the International Monetary Fund at a time of worsening economic outlook for the South Asian nation of 208 million people. (AFP/File)
2 / 2
Asad Umar and with Imran Khan at PTI Workers Convention in 2017 – (Asad Umar Facebook)
Updated 18 April 2019

Pakistan finance minister steps down amid IMF talks, budget preparations

  • Asad Umar says was offered energy ministry by prime minister in cabinet reshuffle but declined
  • Warns no one should expect miracles from the new finance minister

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan’s Finance Minister Asad Umar resigned from the cabinet on Thursday after Prime Minister Imran Khan tried to move him to the energy portfolio, heightening uncertainty about ongoing bailout talks with the International Monetary Fund and the government’s plan to deal with an economy in crisis.
Speculation has been rife in recent days that Umar would be replaced, mostly over delays in reaching a deal with the IMF at a time of worsening economic outlook for the South Asian nation of 208 million people.
“As part of a cabinet reshuffle PM [prime minister] desired that I take the energy minister portfolio instead of finance,” Umar said in a Twitter post. “However, I have obtained his consent to not take any cabinet position.”
At a press conference later in the day, he said Khan needed to pick a new finance minister “as soon as possible” but declined to comment on who would replace him.
Umar’s successor will have the monumental task of not just finalizing the IMF deal but also the national budget, due to be announced in May.
“We are at an advanced stage [of talks] with the IMF and this will also reflect in the upcoming budget,” Umar said. “Whoever comes in, he will have to face a thorny situation … Nobody should expect any miracle from the new finance minister.”
As part of a cabinet reshuffle, Umar said other changes in the cabinet would “be announced either tonight or tomorrow morning.”
Khurram Hussain, the business editor of Dawn newspaper, said Umar’s resignation was “ill-timed” and would add to uncertainty about the country’s economic future.
“At a time when the finance minister was engaged with the IMF and preparing the budget, his resignation is beyond comprehension,” Hussain told Arab News, adding that any new official would now have to start from scratch.
Dr. Athar Ahmed, a senior economist based in Karachi, said Umar’s resignation would shake the confidence of the IMF in Pakistan and possibly prolong the finalization of a deal.
Talks with the IMF began soon after Khan was appointed prime minister but stalled over austerity conditions imposed by the Fund, which has pressed Pakistan to improve tax revenue collection, bolster foreign currency reserves and narrow a current account deficit expected to top 5 percent of gross domestic product this year.
Pakistani officials say they agree on the need for reforms but do not want to sign up to conditions that would derail the economy, with growth set to slow this year to around 4 percent from 5.2 percent last year.
“We have finalized the IMF agreement on much better terms than before as I refused to take decisions that would have crushed the nation,” Umar said at Thursday’s press talk.

Pakistan probes multibillion-rupee losses from cargo misdeclaration

Updated 04 February 2020

Pakistan probes multibillion-rupee losses from cargo misdeclaration

  • Incidents of fraud reported at Torkham, Quetta and Karachi customs stations
  • Automation of the system needed to prevent corruption in duty collection, experts say 

KARACHI: Pakistan’s tax authorities are investigating a series of fraud incidents at the country’s main customs stations, which inflicted multibillion-rupee losses on Pakistan’s economy, an official confirmed on Sunday.

Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) spokesman Hamid Ateeq Sarwar told Arab News an investigation “is underway” and its findings will be shared with the public. 

The FBR’s Directorate General of Customs Intell­igence and Investigation, in early January, uncovered a case involving a network of top officials suspected of a large-scale practice of cargo misdeclaration which it estimates resulted in state losses of billions of rupees.

A report by the directorate sent to the FBR chairman indicated that “organized fraudulent activity (is) taking place at Torkham Customs station through which foreign origin goods are being smuggled.” An initial investigation disclosed that 110 vehicles carrying imported goods have passed the checkpoint on the border with Afghanistan uncharged, the document seen by Arab News reads. 

Similar incidents of misdeclaration were detected in Karachi and Quetta, where more than 900 containers were cleared without paying duties. 

Customs experts are calling for all officials involved in the incidents to be punished. “No matter how influential those involved are they should be given exemplary punishment so that such incidents are prevented in future,” Abdul Qadir Memon, lawyer and former president of the Karachi Tax Bar Association, said.

While corruption appears to be the main obstacle to the FBR’s sound functioning, according to Memon, the problem could be solved by technology. “Automation of the system and installation of scanners at customs stations is key to eliminating corrupt practices. Improvement in the audit system may prevent under-invoicing,” he told Arab News.

The incidents of mass fraud are yet another blow to the FBR, which at the same time is facing a leadership crisis, with its chairman Syed Shabbar Zaidi’s health reportedly deteriorating due to acute stress.

The FBR is also facing a shortfall of around Rs218 billion against its revised revenue target of Rs2.62 trillion set for the July 2019–January 2020 period. 

All these result in an atmosphere of uncertainty, which “is the worst one can afford at this moment. Revenue mobilization is necessary for Pakistan’s economic viability as a state,” taxation expert Dr. Ikram ul Haq told Arab News.

The developments raise concerns over the International Monetary Fund (IMF) second quarterly review of Pakistan’s $6 billion bailout program. IMF representatives arrived in Islamabad on Monday.