Turkish Red Crescent caught in corruption scandal

In this file photo taken on December 12, 2019 shows a view of tents at a camp for displaced Syrians at Khirbet al-Joz in the west of the northwestern Idlib province near the border with Turkey, where residents survive mostly on aid and barely have enough money to buy food and clothes to keep warm. (AFP)
Short Url
Updated 01 February 2020

Turkish Red Crescent caught in corruption scandal

  • The incident causes social uproar and undermines prestige of the aid group

JEDDAH: Turkey’s Red Crescent organization has found itself embroiled in a serious corruption scandal after a document detailing a donation from a private company to the pro-government Ensar Foundation through the humanitarian aid group was revealed.

The corruption, which is believed to go beyond one incident, has caused a social uproar and seriously undermined the prestige of the group.
As all donations made to Turkish Red Crescent are tax deductible, Baskent Gaz — a private natural gas distribution company which is owned by a pro-government business group, Torunlar — gained a tax advantage of about $1.5 million by donating $8 million on Dec. 27, 2017 and recording the donation as expenses.
Afterward, the aid group transferred about $7.9 million to the Ensar Foundation.
What triggered public anger was not only the tax evasion, but also the fact that the donation was made to a foundation which was at the center of a child sexual abuse scandal a year earlier.
A teacher working in a provincial branch of the Foundation was sentenced for sexually abusing 10 male school children between the ages of 10 and 12 from 2012 until 2015. The scandal seriously undermined the image of the foundation, although it has still kept its close ties with the government.
The donation could have been made directly to the infamous Ensar Foundation, but going through Turkish Red Crescent brought significant tax advantages to Baskent Gaz.
Turkish Red Crescent confirmed the transaction with a statement released on Jan. 30, and stated that the money would be used for constructing student dormitories. However, according to the official financial document leaked to the public, Turkish Red Crescent received only $75,000 of this donation.
Turkish Red Crescent refrained from giving a statement to Arab News.
The aid group had already been put under the spotlight when its head, Kerem Kinik, urged Turkish citizens to donate money a few minutes after the deadly earthquake in the eastern province of Elazig on Jan. 24.
The call from Turkish Red Crescent stirred a widespread debate about the effective and transparent usage of earthquake taxes that have been collected from public on an obligatory basis for years.


What triggered public anger was not only the tax evasion, but also the fact that the donation was made to a foundation which was at the center of a child sexual abuse scandal a year earlier.

Public prosecutors quickly launched investigations against several anti-government celebrities in Turkey who used their social media accounts to criticize the misuse of these taxes.
“To evade tax is not the same with avoiding tax. The difference is that in one of them, the state legally gives you a privilege,” Kinik said in a televised interview.
Kinik has also been criticized by nominating his own son, Furkan Kinik, as the vice director of the youth branch of the aid group.
Turkish daily Birgun, known for its leftist credentials, released another document showing that this donation may not be unique in Turkish Red Crescent’s record. Between 2016 and 2018, donations increased by 32 times compared to the previous period.
Birgun drew attention to the fact that many other foundations might have received donations through such a scheme.
Emrah Gulsunar, a political analyst from Lund University in Sweden, thinks that “there is no rule of law in Turkey. The priority for them is the continuation for President Recep Tayyip Erdogan and his ruling AKP regime.”
“The mission of Turkish Red Crescent is not being a meditator for other companies to be tax exempted. This is an apparent abuse of the privilege that is given by laws for bona fides,” he told Arab News.
According to Gulsunar, this move meant using Turkish Red Crescent as a mediator for the purposes of tax evasion.
“Turkish Red Crescent is an accomplice of this operation,” he added.

‘Social explosion’ in Lebanese camps imminent, warn officials

Updated 21 February 2020

‘Social explosion’ in Lebanese camps imminent, warn officials

  • Situation volatile as Palestinian refugees face economic crisis after US peace plan

BEIRUT: Authorities are battling to prevent “a social explosion” among Palestinian refugees crammed into camps in Lebanon, a top official has revealed.

Fathi Abu Al-Ardat, secretary of Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) factions in Lebanon, told Arab News that urgent measures were being put in place to try and stop the “crisis” situation getting out of control.

“Conditions in Palestinian refugee camps in Lebanon are very difficult due to the economic crisis facing the country, and we are trying to delay a social explosion in the camps and working on stopgap solutions,” he said.

And Dr. Hassan Mneimneh, the head of the Lebanese-Palestinian Dialogue Committee (LPDC), said: “More Palestinian refugees from the camps in Lebanon are immigrating. Embassies are receiving immigration requests, and Canada is inundated with a wave of immigration because its embassy has opened doors to applications.”

According to a population census conducted in 2017 by the Central Administration of Statistics in Lebanon, in coordination with the Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics (PCBS), there are 174,422 Palestinian refugees in Lebanon spread across 12 camps and nearby compounds.

Mneimneh insisted the figure was accurate despite the UN Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) estimating there to be 459,292 refugees in the country. He said: “The census we had conducted refers to the current reality in Lebanon.”

He added that he feared “increased pressure on European donor countries over UNRWA in the coming days after the unilateral implementation of the ‘Deal of the Century’ (the US peace plan for the Middle East) by Israel.

“Israel’s goal is to undermine UNRWA’s mission as a prelude to ending the Palestinian cause and, thus, preventing the return of Palestinians.”

Mneimneh held a meeting on Wednesday with two Lebanese and Palestinian action groups in Lebanon to discuss Palestinian asylum issues in light of the American peace plan. There were no representatives of Hezbollah or Hamas present at the talks.

He said: “This deal kick-starts an unusual stage that carries the most serious risks not only to the Palestinian people and cause, but also to the other countries and entities in the Arab region.

“The first of these is Lebanon, which senses the danger of this announcement in view of the clauses it contains to eliminate the Palestinian cause, including the refugee issue and the possibility of their settlement in the host countries.”

Al-Ardat said: “Palestinian refugees have no choice but to withstand the pressures on them to implement the so-called ‘Deal of the Century.’ What is proposed is that we sell our country for promises, delusions, and $50 billion distributed to three countries. Palestine is not for sale.”

He pointed out that “the camps in Lebanon resorted to family solidarity in coordination with the shops in the camps. Whoever does not have money can go to the shop after two (2 p.m.) in the afternoon and get vegetables for free.

“We have been securing 7,000 packs of bread to distribute in the camps and buying the same amount to sell the pack at 500 liras. But this does not solve the problem.”

He added: “The PLO leadership continues to perform its duty toward the refugees and, until now, we have not been affected by the restrictions imposed by banks in Lebanon, and refugees are still receiving medical treatment.

“However, our concern now is that Palestinian refugees do not starve, taking into account all the indications that the situation in Lebanon will not improve soon.

“Twenty percent of the Palestinians in Lebanon receive wages either from UNRWA — as they work there — or from the PLO because they are affiliated with the factions, but 80 percent are unemployed and have no income.”

The meeting hosted by Mneimneh agreed “the categorical rejection of the ‘Deal of the Century’ because it means further erasing the identity existence of the Palestinian people as well as their national rights, especially their right to return and establish their independent state.

“It also means assassinating the Palestinian peoples’ legitimate rights and supporting Israel’s usurpation of international justice and 72 years of Arab struggle.

“The deal includes ambiguous, illegal and immoral approaches that contradict all relevant UN and Security Council resolutions, especially with regard to the establishment of the Palestinian state on the Palestinian territories occupied in 1967 and the inalienable right of Palestinian refugees to return to their homeland and establish their state with Jerusalem as its capital,” a statement on the meeting added.

“UNRWA must remain the living international witness to the ongoing suffering and tragedy of the Palestinian people, and UNRWA must continue to receive support.”

Attendees at the talks also recommended “improving the conditions of the Palestinian refugees in Lebanon to strengthen the elements of their steadfastness until they return.” This was “based on the Unified Lebanese Vision for the Palestinian Refugees Affairs in Lebanon document, which includes the right to work.”