MONTERREY, Mexico, 15 January 2004 — Latin American leaders told President George W. Bush on Tuesday “perverse” US-backed economic policies had failed their nations although they also agreed to fight corruption and terrorism together. Bush tried at a 34-nation Americas summit in Mexico to win back the support of regional leaders after spending the last two years focused almost exclusively on Iraq and security.
Although he earned backing for modest anti-corruption measures and the fight against terrorism, he also heard stinging criticism that rampant free-market policies in the 1990s did nothing to ease poverty and forced countries such as Argentina into deep crisis.
Brazil’s leftist President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva said the “Washington consensus” that promoted market reforms and sweeping privatizations in Latin America did not deliver growth and kept millions hungry in shantytowns and rural villages.
“After the 1980s — the so-called lost decade — the ’90s was a decade of despair,” he said, calling for new policies to tackle poverty directly. “It was a perverse model that wrongly separated the economic from the social, put stability against growth and separated responsibility and justice,” Lula said. “Economic stability turned its back on social justice.”
The Iraq war was widely unpopular in Latin America and countries like Brazil and Argentina have moved to the political left so US-backed policies are no longer an easy sell. President Nestor Kirchner of Argentina, which suffered financial collapse two years ago, said past mistakes were being repeated today and complained he was not getting enough support for his efforts to rebuild the economy and pay off debt.
“We suffer pressures, incomprehension and delays from international organizations which do not appear to understand our need to grow,” he said. “It is unacceptable to insist on recipes that have failed.”
Bush succeeded at the summit in mending his friendship with Mexican President Vicente Fox, who opposed the Iraq war last year. Fox publicly backed Bush’s new immigration reform plan and the two men were all smiles after their meeting on Monday.
Bush also gave Canada’s new Prime Minister Paul Martin a boost on Tuesday by reversing previous policy and announcing Canadian firms would be allowed to bid for some of the $18.6 billion in US-funded reconstruction projects for Iraq.
Bush urged other leaders at the Summit of the Americas in the Mexican city of Monterrey to embrace market reforms and greater democracy and to make quick progress on a contentious Americas-wide free trade deal.
A joint statement at the end of the summit included a commitment to push ahead with a free trade deal between all the nations, with a combined population of 800 million people.
It is supposed to be signed before January 2005 but talks are locked over US agricultural subsidies and US proposals for investment and intellectual property rights rules.
Latin American nations defeated a US proposal that the most corrupt governments in the Americas be barred from regional meetings. They said it was too vague and some feared Washington would use it to isolate its rivals.
Cuban President Fidel Castro is barred from these regional summits, although he has been buoyed in recent years by improved relations with Brazil, Argentina and Venezuela.
Bush again attacked Castro’s rule in a speech on Monday night and urged his fellow leaders to push for democracy on the island, but no one else spoke out against his Communist rule.
A 120-year-old dispute between Bolivia and Chile over an arid strip of Pacific coastline flared up at the talks.