International community urged to stop ‘summary executions’ in Bangladesh



JEDDAH: P.K. ABDUL GHAFOUR

Published — Wednesday 31 October 2012

Last update 31 October 2012 8:36 pm

| نسخة PDF Print News | A A

The trial of Jamaat-e-Islami and BNP leaders in Bangladesh as war criminals has divided the Muslim country. Supporters of the ruling Awami League government alleged the arrested opposition leaders were behind the killings, rapes and other atrocities that occurred during the 1971 liberation war while opponents insist that the trials are politically-motivated as the Hasina government wants to weaken the opposition and continue in power for several years.
Toby M. Cadman, a renowned international barrister and an expert on war crimes tribunals, has called upon the Organization of Islamic Cooperation to hold an international conference either to reconcile the two belligerent groups in Bangladesh or pressure the government to conduct fair and transparent trials.
According to him, the Bangladesh International Crimes Tribunal (ICT) falls short of international standards and violates norms of fair trial spelled out in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, both of which Bangladesh is bound by.
Speaking to Arab News, he recalled a statement made by Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, a former prime minister and father of Hasina, that Bangladeshis are a forgiving nation and that Bangladesh should look to the future not the past in the interest of peace and reconciliation. This was principally the reason for the trials being abandoned in 1973 and resulted in a tripartite agreement between India, Pakistan and Bangladesh.
However, Cadman believed that there should be a judicial process, but that process should be conducted in accordance with universal principles of due process.
Cadman said his recent visit to the Kingdom was aimed at mobilizing international support for preventing what he called “summary executions” of the jailed opposition leaders, including former Jamaat leader Professor Ghulam Azam, Delewar Hossain Sayedee and the present Jamaat president Motiur Rahman Nizami. He called upon Saudi Arabia and other Arab donors of Bangladesh to take immediate steps to ensure a fair trial for the country’s Islamic leaders in accordance with international law.
Cadman said international organizations such as the UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, Amnesty International, the International Bar Association, Human Rights Watch and the International Center for Transitional Justice have expressed their concern over the way the ICT has been operating and urged the Dhaka government to abide by international law and protect human rights of accused persons facing trial.
The United Nations Working Group on Arbitrary Detention concluded earlier this year that all the accused before the ICT are being held arbitrarily and in breach of the international law, the lawyer pointed out. He urged the OIC’s human rights commission to assess the ICT’s working practices and make sure it operates in accordance with international law. He requested the OIC secretary-general to contact the Bangladesh prime minister to raise this issue as a matter of priority.
Cadman insisted that the trial should have been conducted by an international criminal tribunal as people accused of war crimes included not only Bangladeshis but also members of the Indian and Pakistani military and civilian leadership. “There were massive crimes committed by all sides including India and Pakistan. I believe that it should be the subject of an international tribunal because the crimes not only involve the citizens of Bangladesh but also other nationals.”
Cadman wanted prompt action from the international community to prevent unjust judicial proceedings.
“Expressing concern will not be enough. The international community should take quick action to stop the injustice being committed against Jamaat leaders,” he said. Targeting a reputable Islamic party will have dire consequences and will affect Bangladesh’s reputation in the Islamic world, he added.
Cadman, who is a defense adviser for the Jamaat leaders, said he does not expect any justice from the tribunal in light of its present mode of operation. “We cannot expect justice being done for our clients unless the tribunal laws are urgently amended in accordance with the recommendations of the international organizations and Ambassador-at-Large for War-Crimes Issues, Stephen J. Rapp.”
Bangladesh has banned Cadman from entering the country after he had spoken publically against the situation in the country. “I realized that I have become an irritation for the government as I have been criticizing a process that they deem is in accordance with international standards and bring justice to victims, which is quite far from the actual situation,” he said.
Referring to his meeting with EU Parliament members, Cadman said: “I was trying to convince the international community that what is going on in Bangladesh is a grave miscarriage of justice. If they pass death sentences, which they intend to and execute the Jamaat leaders following trials in breach of proper standards, it would amount to summary execution because the trials have been unfair,” he explained. Cadman said the EU had insisted that the judicial process in Bangladesh should comply with international legal standards. It had also urged Bangladesh to abolish death penalty.
Spelling out the evidence to prove that the ICT does not comply with the international law, he said: “The present law in Bangladesh is outdated; there are no clear definitions for war crimes; prosecution had called only a small number of witnesses and few of whom are able to provide any direct evidence; the judicial procedures lack transparency in many respects; we cannot challenge the jurisdiction of tribunal, the legislation, the appointment of judges and the tribunal’s decisions; the same judges are conducting investigation, issuing decisions and reviewing their own decisions; and there is a very limited time for the defense to prepare.” Cadman said the Tribunal has arrested those leaders who may have opposed independence.
“Opposing independence is not a crime,” he pointed out. He agreed that the Hasina government was showing its political vendetta by arresting the leading members of Jamaat and BNP. “It is actually punishing the Jamaat for siding with the last BNP government. If the government wants to end the culture of impunity, it should depoliticize the judicial process and appoint international judges and prosecutors, and there should be a foreign council for the defense and government members should stop making comments in breach of the presumption of innocence.”
Cadman called for a completely fresh review of the whole proceedings of the ICT. “I would be failing in my duty as a member of the Bar of England and Wales if I did not do everything possible to support my clients. I want them to be acquitted following a fair trial.” He stressed the need for educating the international community about the grave situation in Bangladesh.
Speaking about the oldest defendant, Professor Ghulam Azam, he said there is no reasonable basis for not releasing him on bail. “Azam is not in a position to influence the proceedings or witnesses. We hope he would be released soon to be in the care of his family. Azam and the other Jamaat leaders are well respected members of their community and deserve better treatment,” he added.

What's happening around Saudi Arabia

ABHA: Several Saudi businesswomen started traveling with a group of friends after recent regulations which allow women to travel without their mahram. These women said they find great fun to travel as a group with their friends and their children, wh...
RIYADH: The United Nations, Arab League and Gulf Cooperation Council welcomed the Kingdom-led coalition’s announcement of a five-day cease-fire, that took effect at midnight on Sunday, to push humanitarian relief in war-ravaged Yemen to the beleaguer...
ALKHOBAR: Jobless Saudi women constitute 70 percent of the unemployed. The Ministry of Economy and Planning said 58 percent of the jobless have preparatory school level education. According to the statistics, the annual unemployment growth rate among...
RIYADH: Saudi Arabia has found traces of a civilization that was domesticating horses about 9,000 years ago, 4,000 years earlier than previously thought. The discovery has shed new light on the origin of the Arabian horse, which has remained a great...
RIYADH: The Ministry of Labor in the Makkah region found 250 laborers working on various construction projects during restricted hours of the day. Punitive measures will be taken against the employers of these workers. According to a ministerial decr...
JEDDAH: When poverty is your guest for 15 years, gardens, parks, streets and pavements become your abode under the unavoidable scorching sun. One has to face hardships of hunger and survive on breadcrumbs. This is the situation of a 60-year-old Saudi...
JEDDAH: The negative attitudes of society in dealing with harassment and abuse cases prevent victims from reporting a great number of such cases to the authorities.Despite this, about 3,982 cases reached the country's criminal courts in 1435 and 1436...
AL-QATIF: The Omani security forces have arrested a man who, they said, accidentally fired a bullet that hit a young Saudi girl in a hotel in Musandam on Saturday. Four-year-old Zainab bint Mohammed Labad of Al-Awamiyah was playing in the hotel lobby...
Ramon Corvera, deputy chief of mission at the Argentinian Embassy in Riyadh.* Which particular aspect of Saudi Arabia you like the most? The natural beauty of the desert.* What is your favorite and oft-repeated Arabic word? Masha’Allah.* Which book i...
JEDDAH: The creativity and entrepreneurship community program of Umm Al-Qura University brought together 80 creative entrepreneurs to exchange their experiences and knowledge on Monday. Fawaz Saad, the dean of the institute for innovation and entrepr...
RIYADH: The August issue of ‘Nature’, the monthly magazine of King Abdulaziz City for Science and Technology (KACST), will focus on Middle East Respiratory Syndrome (MERS) corona, which has affected 1,055 people in the Kingdom since June 2012.The to...
LILLE, France: Saudi Arabia’s firm stand against the phenomenon of violence as well as religious, ethnic and cultural fanaticism came in for praise at an international symposium, which concluded here.The participants of the symposium on "Media Covera...
DAMMAM: Saudi Arabian Boy Scouts Association (SABSA) is participating in the 23rd World Scout Jamboree with the slogan “A Spirit of Unity,” which starts July 28 and runs until August 8 in Kirara-hama, Japan. A total of 32,000 scouts from 144 national...
JEDDAH: The Ministry of Labor was able to increase the number of Saudi women employees from 70,000 to 428,000 during the past four years, Abdul Munim Al-Shehri, assistant undersecretary for special programs, has said . The ministry is now working on...
JEDDAH: A court issued a 10-year prison sentence against a health employee in Al-Ahsa and fined him SR1 million for getting involved in forgery and fraud as well as embezzling public funds in contracts to import medical equipment for the Children and...

Stay Connected

Facebook