Although Pat Monahan has fronted the group for over a decade, he's never been a household name, and people who know the chorus of "Soul Sister" probably wouldn't be able to name Train's other two members, guitarist Jimmy Stafford and drummer Scott Underwood. Monahan acknowledges that kind of anonymous success used to grate on him — but he puts the emphasis on "used to." "Being under the radar as a celebrity isn't the worst thing that can happen to you. I think that maybe that's the reason for the longevity," says Monahan. "For a long time I was disappointed about it. It was like, 'How come I can't get on Us Weekly, how come we're not on the cover of Rolling Stone? What did we do wrong?' But now I think that we just don't care like that. That's not why we started this. ... So we're learning how to have a lot of fun with it and keeping in mind that thinking about celebrity is thinking about the wrong thing. Thinking about the music is thinking about the future."