Cleric, archaeologist clash over whether Sphinx represents Prophet Idris

Former grand mufti Ali Gomaa, left, and Archaeologist Zahy Hawwas
Short Url
Updated 30 April 2020

Cleric, archaeologist clash over whether Sphinx represents Prophet Idris

  • Ali Gomaa: Prophet Idris was the first to start building the pyramids
  • Zahy Hawwas: There is no need for a cleric to talk about archaeology

CAIRO: A war of words is being waged in Egypt between prominent archaeologist and former Minister of Antiquities Zahy Hawwas and Egypt’s former Grand Mufti Ali Gomaa. 

The row broke out following Gomaa’s comments about who built the pyramids. He said that Prophet Idris was probably the first to start construction of the famed structures, and that the Sphinx represents Prophet Idris. 

Gomaa — who, as the grand mufti, issued legal opinions interpreting Islamic law and is a member of Egypt’s top scholastic authority — told the TV show “Egypt the Land of Prophets” that “there are many probabilities discussed by scholars that Prophet Idris was the first to start building the pyramids and that he taught the science of mummification, and that the face of the Sphinx is Idris’ face.” 

Following the show’s broadcast, Hawwas issued a statement refuting Gomaa’s claims. “There is no need for a religious cleric to talk about archaeology, especially (considering) he gave incorrect information that is totally irrelevant to archaeology,” Hawwas said. 

“A long time ago, Dr. Mustafa Mahmoud — in his famous program (“Science and Faith”) gave the same incorrect information (which is) a repetition of what Arab travelers said when they came to Egypt in the 19th century.” 

He called on Gomaa to prove that Prophet Idris built the pyramids or that he bore any likeness to the Sphinx. 

“Firstly, we have full evidence that King Djoser built the first pyramid, and that the genius Imhotep changed the construction material from mud bricks to stones,” Hawwas said. “We have the oldest papyri found up to now — which is the Wadi El-Garf papyri — where the chief of workers Merer talks about the Khufu Pyramid, saying that the area around the pyramids was known as Ankh Khufu, meaning Khufu lives, and that Khufu lived in a palace at the pyramids. 

“As for the Sphinx, it does not date back to the pre-Khufu and Khafra era as Sheikh Ali Gomaa said,” Hawwas continued. “This is a huge mistake because all the scientific evidence proves that the Sphinx dates back to the King Khafra era. It was engraved to show King Khafra in the form of Horus. The ancient Egyptians linked the king’s strength and the lion’s — the Sphinx has the body of a lion and a human head,” he said. 

As for mummification, Hawas said “Prophet Idris did not teach mummification because Egyptians learned mummification in stages, beginning with the first dynasty, when they used to dry the corpses while adding some substances on the legs. Later, the process improved and they started making masks during the fourth dynasty. Mummification reached its peak only during the 18th dynasty.” 

Gomaa replied: “Old friend Dr. Zahy Hawwas did not see the program but rather depended on what the media reported. Had Hawwas seen the program, he would have known that we differentiate between scientific stories and folk stories. He would also have known that it is a show that highlights how Egyptians belong to their country and how much they love it. Moreover, the show underlines Egypt’s historical location, which many people might not pay attention to.” 

Historical researcher Mahmoud Hassan told Arab News that claims that Prophet Idris is the Sphinx are mentioned in many prominent history books, the latest of which is “The Shining Stars” by Bin Tighri Berdi, issued during the Mamluk era in Egypt. 

“Furthermore, many other books before that talked about the same issue,” he said. 

Hassan added that a number of historians had written about Pharaonic historical events, citing Al-Waleed bin Mosaab’s explanation of the Holy Qur’an, in which he wrote about how Moses and his people left Egypt, and the Pharoah’s story. In his book “The Beginning and the End,” Ibn Katheer wrote that the Pharaoh’s name was Haitham. Hassan added that what religious clerics refer to these days is derived from books on heritage, “which need revision.” 

Researcher Abdel-Meguid Abdel-Aziz told Arab News that, throughout history, religious clerics have always linked prophets to various historical eras.


Egypt’s El-Sisi warns of instability after protest calls

Updated 31 min 57 sec ago

Egypt’s El-Sisi warns of instability after protest calls

  • El-Sisi thanked Egyptians for not heeding the calls, saying the government was undertaking the measures as part of reforms
  • The small-scale demonstrations come amid mounting anger against government campaigns to stop illegal construction

CAIRO: Egypt’s President Abdel Fattah El-Sisi warned on Sunday against attempts to stoke instability in the country, following a recent spate of scattered and small-scale anti-government protests.
“Some people have been trying in recent weeks to take advantage of the tough measures we are taking,” El-Sisi said at a ceremony to inaugurate an oil refining complex north of Cairo.
“They choose the hard conditions to harm and cast doubts among Egyptians over what we do.”
Dozens of people took part in rare protests in recent days in several villages in Egypt, according to videos shared widely on social media, especially by sympathizers of the Muslim Brotherhood, an outlawed group.
The small-scale demonstrations come amid mounting anger, particularly in rural and low-income areas, against sweeping government campaigns to stop illegal construction, which have required people to pay fines to legalize home-ownership.
Exiled businessman Mohamed Ali, who has urged anti-El-Sisi protests since last year, has intensified his calls in recent weeks in online videos, calling on Egyptians take to the streets against the government.
During his speech, El-Sisi thanked Egyptians for not heeding the calls, saying the government was undertaking the measures as part of reforms.
On Saturday, family and medical sources said a man was killed in clashes between protesters and police in a village south of Cairo.