Suspension of judge in Beirut port blast brings investigations back to square one

Suspension of judge in Beirut port blast brings investigations back to square one
The Aug. 4, 2020 Beirut port blast killed hundreds, injured thousands and destroyed large swathes of the capital Beirut. (Reuters)
Short Url
Updated 27 September 2021

Suspension of judge in Beirut port blast brings investigations back to square one

Suspension of judge in Beirut port blast brings investigations back to square one
  • Judge Tareq Bitar stops all procedures related to the file pending a decision on appeal filed by MP Nohad Al-Machnouk

BEIRUT: Judge Tareq Bitar, the judicial investigator into the Beirut port explosion, was informed on Monday that he had been suspended from the case after MP Nohad Al-Machnouk filed an appeal against him last week.

Bitar suspended his investigation and all procedures related to the file, pending a decision by the Beirut Appeals Court to accept or reject the appeal filed by Al-Machnouk.

Bitar was appointed on Feb. 19 as the second judge to lead the investigation into the explosion, after Judge Fadi Sawan. On Feb. 18, Sawan was suspended from the file, four months after his appointment to lead the investigation, following requests by former ministers Ali Hassan Khalil and Ghazi Zuaiter, whom Sawan charged in relation to the incident, with the file was transferred due to “legitimate suspicion.”

The disaster, which shook the world on Aug. 4, 2020, claimed the lives of 215 people, injured more than 6,500 and destroyed the waterfront of the Lebanese capital. It was caused by the ignition of ammonium nitrate, part of a cache estimated at 2,750 tons, according to official estimates, which was stored in silo number 12 of the port, along with quantities of other seized explosives.

It was confiscated from a ship docked in the port in 2014.

Bitar and Sawan included in their accusations former Prime Minister Hassan Diab, several other current ministers and MPs, senior army officers, general and state security officers, senior employees at the port, as well as some judges.

The allegations were based on crimes related to negligence, causing the death of more than 200 people, wounding thousands of people, some of them seriously with physical deformities and permanent disabilities, in addition to the destruction of the port and its facilities, as well as multiple homes and public and private properties.

Bitar had interrogated on Monday the former intelligence chief, Jawdat Oweidat, and began holding a session to interrogate Brig. Gen. Kamil Daher and Brig. Gen. Ghassan Gharzeddine in the case, when he was informed of the decision to suspend him.

Arab News learned from a judicial source that, last Friday, Bitar referred the attorney general, Judge Ghassan Khoury, to the Public Prosecutor at the Court of Cassation, and requested a case against him for “filing away the ammonium nitrate file when it was in his possession.”

The process of prosecuting judges is the responsibility of the Public Prosecutor at the Court of Cassation and not to the judicial investigator in the crime.

The decision to suspend Bitar is official, but it is not final, pending the decision of the Court of Appeal. If Al-Machnouk’s request is accepted, then matters will return to square one.

Former Minister Youssef Fenianos, a defendant in the case, had previously submitted a “request to transfer the explosion file from Judge Bitar due to legitimate suspicion.”

Bitar renewed his referral to the Public Prosecution two new requests addressed to the minister of interior and the General Secretariat of the Council of Ministers, requesting permission to prosecute the Director General of General Security Maj. Gen. Abbas Ibrahim, and the Director General of State Security Maj. Gen. Tony Saliba.

Bitar had set Sept. 30 to interrogate Minister Ali Hassan Khalil, Oct. 1 for the interrogation of ministers Ghazi Zuaiter and Al-Machnouk, and Oct. 4 as a new date for hearing former Prime Minister Hassan Diab, who is in the US, after Bitar decided to inform him of the date of his interrogation session.

Former Public Prosecutor Judge Hatem Madi said that “when the judiciary is shaken, this means that a mistake has occurred.” He told Arab News: “There is a crime that took place in the port of Beirut. The first judicial investigator was removed and now the second judicial investigator is being removed. How long will this interaction with the judiciary continue? Is there an intention to appoint a third judicial investigator? What if he followed in the footsteps of the two previous judges? Are they going to remove him, too? (Are they going to continue) until the judiciary is empty of its judges, or will they resort to judges from another planet?”

Madi said that “when the opponent is suspicious of the impartiality of the judge, he is afraid that he will judge against his interest.”

On whether Bitar is impartial in his work, Madi said: “When a judge works, someone stands against him, even if he is just. Usually, judges bypass this. I do not know the criminal policy followed by Judge Bitar, but what he has done so far is good, it is professional, and there is no doubt about it. As for why he chose this method and not another method, the file is his responsibility and he is the boss, and he chose the path that he saw fit. It does not mean that he made a mistake.”

Bitar received threats from Hezbollah to remove him from the file. The first threat was by Hezbollah Secretary-General Hassan Nasrallah last August, who publicly accused him of “politicizing” the case, adding: “Either he (Bitar) adheres to a clear technical investigation, or the judiciary must find another judge.”

The second threat came from Hezbollah’s security and liaison officer, Wafiq Safa, who went last week to the Palace of Justice in Beirut and met with several judges. He told Lara Al-Hashem, a journalist at the Palace of Justice, to deliver a message to Bitar, saying: “We are tired of you. We will follow the legal path to the end, and if the situation does not go well, we will uproot you.”

Al-Hashem revealed on Sunday that she “delivered the message to Judge Bitar, and his response was: “Wafiq Safa is right, no matter how my uprooting process was.”

She said that she also conveyed Safa’s message to the discriminatory Public Prosecutor. She added that there was “data of communications, surveillance cameras and witnesses, and I am under the roof of the law.”

Hezbollah’s threats sparked outrage within the judiciary, but it did not reach the level of public mass condemnation.

Imad Wakim, a member of the Lebanese Forces Party’s parliamentary bloc, commented on the suspension of Bitar from the file, tweeting: “Do you want Wafiq Safa as a judicial investigator?”

 


Beirut blast probe judge cleared to continue investigation

Beirut blast probe judge cleared to continue investigation
Updated 6 sec ago

Beirut blast probe judge cleared to continue investigation

Beirut blast probe judge cleared to continue investigation
  • A Beirut court rejected the last of the suits preventing Tarek Bitar from questioning top officials
BEIRUT: The probe into last year’s deadly Beirut port blast has been cleared to resume after being suspended for more than a month on legal claims against its lead investigator, judge Tarek Bitar, a judicial source said.
A Beirut court rejected the last of the suits preventing Bitar from questioning top officials on Tuesday.
“They have reversed the decision that had led to the suspension of the probe and he can now resume his work for sure,” Nizar Saghieh, head of the Legal Agenda, a research and advocacy organization, told Reuters.
The resumption could be temporary should further legal complaints be filed, he said.
The investigation into the Aug. 4, 2020, blast that killed more than 215 people, injured thousands and destroyed large swathes of the city has made little headway amid pushback from powerful factions, some of whom lead smear campaigns and filed multiple suits against Bitar.
The leader of the Iranian-backed, armed Shiite Muslim political movement Hezbollah has repeatedly said he wanted Bitar removed from the case and the row over him has spilled over into government, with Prime Minister Najib Mikati’s cabinet unable to meet since Oct. 12.
Many Lebanese are angry that more than one year on from the blast no senior official has been held accountable for the country’s worst peace-time disaster as it slips into political and economic meltdown.
Bitar has sought to question senior politicians, including former ministers and members of parliament, since July but nearly all have spurned him.
He is the second judge to take charge of the investigation after a legal complaint against the partiality of his predecessor Fady Sawan saw him removed in February.

Motorcycle explosion in southern Iraqi city kills at least 4

Motorcycle explosion in southern Iraqi city kills at least 4
Updated 07 December 2021

Motorcycle explosion in southern Iraqi city kills at least 4

Motorcycle explosion in southern Iraqi city kills at least 4

BASRA: At least four people were killed and 20 wounded in an explosion in Iraq's southern city of Basra, police and hospital sources told Reuters on Tuesday.
Police are still investigating the cause of the blast, which took place in the city centre, near a main hospital. The explosion set fire to at least one vehicle and damaged a minibus.
One police source said that an initial investigation showed that a motorcycle rigged with explosives could have been the cause of the blast. 


UAE government switches weekend to Saturday-Sunday starting 2022

UAE government switches weekend to Saturday-Sunday starting 2022
Updated 07 December 2021

UAE government switches weekend to Saturday-Sunday starting 2022

UAE government switches weekend to Saturday-Sunday starting 2022
  • The decision is aimed at boosting productivity and improving work-life balance, WAM reported

DUBAI: The UAE government will transition to a four-and-a-half-day working week, with Friday afternoon, Saturday and Sunday forming the new weekend starting Jan. 1, 2022 for all federal departments, state news agency WAM reported. 
The new system will be applied in all federal government entities with working hours from 7:30 a.m. till 3:30 p.m., it added.
Working hours on Fridays will start at 7:30 a.m. and end at 12 noon, with the possibility of flexible working hours or work from home options during those days. Friday sermons and prayers will be after 1:15 p.m. all year long in the UAE. 
The decision is aimed at boosting productivity and improving work-life balance, WAM reported.


UAE’s new 50-dirham banknote features Sheikh Zayed

UAE’s new 50-dirham banknote features Sheikh Zayed
Updated 07 December 2021

UAE’s new 50-dirham banknote features Sheikh Zayed

UAE’s new 50-dirham banknote features Sheikh Zayed
  • It is the first polymer banknote to be circulated in the country
  • The current 50- dirham note will continue to be used

DUBAI: UAE rulers witnessed the launch of a new 50-dirham banknote on Tuesday, in celebration of the country’s 50th National Day. 
The initiative comes in honor of the UAE’s founding father, the late Sheikh Zayed bin Sultan Al-Nahyan, and the country’s first generation of rulers to commemorate their dedication and historical role in uniting the country.
It is the first polymer banknote to be circulated in the country.
“We see in this issuance the new phase that UAE will enter, and a renewed pledge to continue its growth path. The occasion also allowed us to express our appreciation and gratitude to our founding fathers by issuing a new AED50 banknote to celebrate the fiftieth anniversary of the establishment of the UAE,” said Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed Al-Nahyan, Deputy Prime Minister and Chairman of the Board of Directors of the Central Bank of the UAE. 
The front of the new banknote features a portrait of the late Sheikh Zayed on the right, and the memorial picture of the founding fathers after signing the union document. 
Meanwhile, the back side includes a picture of the late Sheikh Zayed signing the union agreement as well as illustration of the Etihad Museum, which witnessed the establishment of the union and the raising of the UAE flag for the first time.
According to state news agency WAM, the new banknote will be available in Central Bank branches and ATMs ‘in the near future’.
The current 50- dirham note will continue to be used.
Polymer banknotes are said to be more durable and sustainable than traditional cotton paper banknotes, lasting two or more times longer in circulation. They can also be completely recycled, thus reducing their environmental footprint.


Syria says fires extinguished at Latakia’s port following Israeli ‘aggression’

 Israeli Air Force F-35 fighter jets fly over the Mediterranean Sea. (REUTERS file photo)
Israeli Air Force F-35 fighter jets fly over the Mediterranean Sea. (REUTERS file photo)
Updated 07 December 2021

Syria says fires extinguished at Latakia’s port following Israeli ‘aggression’

 Israeli Air Force F-35 fighter jets fly over the Mediterranean Sea. (REUTERS file photo)
  • Israel has mounted frequent attacks against what it has described as Iranian targets in Syria

CAIRO: Fires caused by an Israeli “aggression” at Syria’s Latakia port on Tuesday had been extinguished, leaving material damage, but the status of any casualties was unclear, Syria’s state media reported.

Five explosions rocked the port city after an Israeli “aggression” hit the port’s container yard, sending fire trucks racing to the site, Syrian state TV said.

Israel has mounted frequent attacks against what it has described as Iranian targets in Syria, where Tehran-backed forces including Lebanon’s Hezbollah have deployed over the last decade to support President Bashar Assad.

The Mediterranean port of Latakia is the country’s main port, through which food and other crucial supplies flow into war-torn Syria, and is close to Russia’s main air base of Hmeimim.