PARIS, 31 August 2003 — It will take months for the French government to recover from the political fallout of its handling of August’s heat wave which killed about 11,400 people. It will take far longer for politicians to come to terms with the new-found aggression of the French press.
In the space of a few weeks, the press’s historically subservient approach to the government has been replaced with a new tone of vitriol. The nation’s health minister was hounded for his failure to avert the deaths.
Even in the right-wing papers the headlines were stark. ‘The heat wave is killing people,’ Le Figaro announced on Aug. 11 — long before the government accepted that it had a problem on its hands, and days before the prime minister and the health minister saw fit to abandon their holidays.
“A national healthcare catastrophe,” Le Parisien warned two days later. Judged by its own more forthright standards, the left-wing daily Liberation was unrestrained in its criticism, covering its front page with the words, the “Government Under the Grill”, orange flames curling around each letter.
The gravity of the situation combined with the sluggish official response triggered howls of fury from the media, which demanded an official inquiry. Media analysts have begun asking whether the troubled summer will mark a revolution in the traditionally restrained and complicit nature of the French media.
Daniel Schneidermann, France’s leading media commentator and a columnist for Le Monde, said: “I can’t remember an occasion on which the press responded in such a critical way. They were pugnacious to a degree that is extremely unusual in France, even if by the standards of the British press there was nothing remarkable about its coverage. I found it extremely surprising.”
Despite the mounting death toll, President Jacques Chirac decided not to cut short his holiday in Canada. He expressed his sorrow at the deaths of UN workers in Iraq but made no comment on reports that thousands were dying in France. The newspapers responded with bemused outrage.
The way that the heat wave was handled laid bare the extent of the political power vacuum that reigns in France every August. Newspaper offices and television studios, obliged to continue reporting on a daily basis, saw the impending catastrophe long before any senior politician did, simply because almost all of the government was on holiday.
Oliver Costemalle, media correspondent for Liberation, explained: “When the heat wave began to turn bad, newspapers devoted all their energy, staff, resources and space to covering it.”
The turning point came with the broadcast interview with the health minister on Aug. 11, ten days after the record-breaking temperatures began to sweep through France and just as news of the first deaths was emerging. Jean-Francois Mattei was shown in a T-shirt, in the garden of his villa in the south of France, flatly dismissing reports of an impending catastrophe. His words were transmitted immediately after reports showing doctors in Paris unable to cope with the sudden influx of heat victims and funeral workers complaining that they were having problems burying the bodies fast enough.
The French government’s alarm at this new phenomenon of a ferocious media is evident in the defensive measures it has taken. One of the prime minister’s media handlers took the unprecedented step of making a written complaint to Agence France Presse about its use of the expression “power vacuum”, complaining that this was plucked from the mouth of the Socialist Party leader.
Another official tried in vain to force the head of France 2 to stop broadcasting footage of the prime minister running downstairs, pursued by journalists demanding to know why the official response had been so slow.
“For years the French media has been criticized for its reticence; this summer may mark the beginning of a shift toward the extremes of British newspapers,” Schneidermann said.
“They have a long way to go before they register anywhere near the British aggression on a Richter scale; but this summer we have seen the intensity of their attacks creep higher up the scale.”
