Indecisiveness on key economic issues sparks confusion in Pakistan, experts say

“Up until now, all previous finance ministers would have made decisions, but Asad Umar is making committees on every issue instead of taking prompt decisions. His role as finance minister is quickly becoming that of a coordinator between task forces and committees,” Muzamil Aslam, senior economist and CEO of EFG-Hermes Pakistan, said.

• Pakistan’s economic situation poses a challenge to the new government as the current account deficit in July 2018 jumped to a whopping $2.2 billion due to an increase in imports and an insufficient foreign inflow
• Authorities fail to reach consensus on whether or not to approach the IMF

KARACHI: Pakistan’s newly-elected government continues to worry the business fraternity with its indecisiveness and backtracking on key economic issues, experts told Arab News on Saturday.
The cabinet, led by Prime Minister Imran Khan, was formed on August 20 but has yet to take a major economic decision to allay investors’ fears.
It also remains to be seen whether or not the International Monetary Fund (IMF) will be approached for a bailout package. “There is a major difference between the information they [PTI government] obtained before and after the elections; in fact, the difference is so enormous that they are confused as to how to handle the information in terms of decision making,” Muzamil Aslam, senior economist and CEO of EFG-Hermes Pakistan, said.
Questioning the decision-making ability of Finance Minister Asad Umar, he added: “Up until now, all previous finance ministers would have made decisions, but Asad Umar is making committees on every issue instead of taking prompt decisions. His role as finance minister is quickly becoming that of a coordinator between task forces and committees.”
Pakistan’s economic situation poses a challenge to the new government as the current account deficit in July 2018 jumped to a whopping $2.2 billion due to an increase in imports and an insufficient foreign inflow. The country’s foreign exchange reserves have fallen to $9.9 billion — not enough to meet import obligations of even two months.
The government was expected to deliberate on the issue during the first meeting of the newly-constituted Economic Advisory Committee (EAC), but the meeting, chaired by Prime Minister Imran Khan on Thursday, concluded after the initial introductions.
Dr. Ashfaque Hassan Khan, a member of the EAC, who attended the meeting said: “Though IMF was not discussed at all in the meeting, my personal view is that we should live without the IMF.”
Speaking to Arab News he said: “Instead of taking medicines periodically temporarily, we should diagnose the illness and take remedial measures once for all.”
Dr. Khan said that the prime minister shared his vision of a welfare state and was determined to improve the lives of the poor.
Following the meeting, the stock market closed at 411 points lower, mainly on the weekend, due to the indecisiveness of the government to tackle key economic issues, with external financing topping the list.
“The market is in negative because investors are confused as to how the new government’s economic managers will act considering the rising current account and fiscal deficit. Moreover, there is no clarity on how the dollar funding gap will be bridged – whether this will be done with the support of the IMF or another source,” Muhammad Sohail, CEO of Topline Securities, explained to Arab News. 
During the week, the stock market shed 883 points, falling below the 41,000 level, erasing most of the gains made in the period post the 2018 general elections. 
Recently, the government was caught in the crossfire following the appointment of Dr. Atif R Mian from the minority Ahmadi community. Ahmadis were declared non-Muslim by the parliament on September 7, 1974.
Information Minister Fawad Chaudhary, defending the government’s stance, had vowed not to bow down before people whom he declared as “extremists”. On Friday, however, the government backtracked and withdrew Mian’s nomination.
“The government wants to take religious scholars and all other segments of society along with them in their decision-making process and if one nomination gives a perception that it is different from the government’s aim, then it is not appropriate,” Chaudhary tweeted.
“Until yesterday they [the government] were defending his [Dr. Atif R Mian] appointment,” Aslam responded, adding that, “they are now shaking because reality has kicked in.”
Dr. Ikramul Haq, a senior economist lamenting the move, said: “This is a disappointment for all those who are concerned about extremists holding the state captive. The right of a citizen, irrespective of their faith, is equal under the constitution. Removal of his name from the advisory body amounts to a violation of Article 25 of the constitution which pertains to the protection of equal rights and does not allow discrimination on the basis of faith, cast and creed etc.”