Will AI destroy democracy or be its savior?

Will AI destroy democracy or be its savior?

Will AI destroy democracy or be its savior?
Even the most sophisticated AI systems are only as good as the data they’re fed. (Shutterstock image)
Short Url

Will AI destroy democracy or be its savior?In the bustling metropolis of Techville, where neon-lit skyscrapers and algorithm-driven traffic lights rule the streets, the latest buzz isn’t about the newest gadget or the trendiest AI companion. No, the citizens of Techville are grappling with a weightier issue — democracy and how AI might be its ruin or its savior.

The idea that AI could one day manage democracies has moved from science fiction to serious discourse in Techville’s coffee shops and university halls. Over a latte, the city’s philosophers debate whether AI could enhance the democratic process or if it’s a slippery slope toward technocratic tyranny.

The great expert on democracies, a figure whose name you’ll hear whispered with a mix of reverence and concern, once said: “Their worst enemy is the inequality between rich and poor.” It’s hard to imagine how a silicon-based overlord, devoid of human emotion, could tackle such a deeply human issue. Yet, here we are, asking: Could AI help resolve the growing chasm between the haves and the have-nots, or will it merely exacerbate it?

Let’s start with the concerns. Erica Benner, political philosopher and author of Adventures in Democracy, has much to say on the matter. “The dangers that threaten our political system are multifaceted,” she warns. And before you think she’s about to extol the virtues of a well-educated electorate, Benner throws us a curveball. “The solution,” she argues, “is not necessarily to have more educated citizens.”

Benner’s argument is both refreshing and unsettling. She suggests that the problem isn’t just the voters, but the very framework of democracy itself. In an AI-managed democracy, the risk isn’t just that the uneducated masses might be swayed by clever algorithms. The bigger issue is that AI could institutionalize biases, effectively cementing existing inequalities. In other words, the system that should be freeing us could end up shackling us in new ways.

Imagine an AI, designed to maximize efficiency and stability, which determines that the best way to run a country is by reinforcing the status quo. If the rich are happy, and the poor are pacified with just enough resources to keep them quiet, why change anything? The inequality that our democracy expert warned about could become a permanent feature — no longer a bug, but an intentional design choice.

There’s a certain allure to the idea of AI-driven governance. Algorithms, after all, aren’t susceptible to bribes, they don’t get tired, and they don’t have a stake in the next election cycle.

Rafael Hernandez de Santiago

But let’s not throw the AI out with the bathwater just yet. The optimists in Techville have a different vision. They see AI as the tool that could finally perfect democracy, eliminating corruption, inefficiency, and perhaps even the inequality that plagues our current systems. In a city where even the street sweepers discuss Kant over their morning coffee, the idea of an AI philosopher-king doesn’t seem so far-fetched.

There’s a certain allure to the idea of AI-driven governance. Algorithms, after all, aren’t susceptible to bribes, they don’t get tired, and they don’t have a stake in the next election cycle. “Imagine a world where policies are based purely on data,” muses one of Techville’s more starry-eyed tech entrepreneurs, “where decisions are made without the messy business of human emotions and biases.”

Yet, even the most sophisticated AI systems are only as good as the data they’re fed. And as any Techvillian worth their coding skills will tell you, data can be messy, biased, and incomplete. The irony here is rich. The very tools that promise to perfect democracy could end up corrupting it from within, not through malice or intent, but through the cold, unfeeling logic that AI thrives on.

Techville’s streets may be clean, and its governance hyper-efficient, but beneath the surface, the philosophical debate rages on. Can a democracy managed by AI truly be democratic? Or would it be democracy in name only, with the real power held by the engineers and data scientists behind the curtain?

There’s a delicious irony in the fact that the very tools we’ve created to serve us might end up ruling us instead. As Benner wryly notes in Adventures in Democracy: “Perhaps the greatest adventure of all is the one where we realize that the map we’ve been following leads us right back to where we started.”

In a city where irony is the local dialect and debate a civic duty, the discussion is far from over. Should we reinvent democracy to include our new AI overlords? Or should we be cautious, remembering that the tools we build to solve our problems often create new ones in their wake?

One thing is clear. Democracy, like any good piece of technology, might need a few updates. But whether those updates should be coded by humans or by AI is a question that even the smartest bots in Techville have yet to answer.

Rafael Hernandez de Santiago, viscount of Espes, is a Spanish national residing in Saudi Arabia and working at the Gulf Research Center.


 

Disclaimer: Views expressed by writers in this section are their own and do not necessarily reflect Arab News' point of view

Heathrow resumes operations as global airlines scramble after shutdown

Heathrow resumes operations as global airlines scramble after shutdown
Updated 10 min 10 sec ago
Follow

Heathrow resumes operations as global airlines scramble after shutdown

Heathrow resumes operations as global airlines scramble after shutdown
  • Flights began to resume late on Friday
  • British Airways warns of ‘huge impact’ in coming days

LONDON: London’s Heathrow Airport resumed full operations on Saturday, a day after a fire knocked out its power supply and shut Europe’s busiest airport, causing global travel chaos.
The travel industry was scrambling to reroute passengers and fix battered airline schedules after the huge fire at an electrical substation serving the airport.
Some flights had resumed on Friday evening, but the shuttering of the world’s fifth-busiest airport for most of the day left tens of thousands searching for scarce hotel rooms and replacement seats while airlines tried to return jets and crew to bases.
Teams were working across the airport to support passengers affected by the outage, a Heathrow spokesperson said in an emailed statement.
“We have hundreds of additional colleagues on hand in our terminals and we have added flights to today’s schedule to facilitate an extra 10,000 passengers traveling through the airport,” the spokesperson said.
The travel industry, facing the prospect of a financial hit costing tens of millions of pounds and a likely fight over who should pay, questioned how such crucial infrastructure could fail without backup.
“It is a clear planning failure by the airport,” said Willie Walsh, head of global airlines body IATA, who, as former head of British Airways, has for years been a fierce critic of the crowded hub.
The airport had been due to handle 1,351 flights on Friday, flying up to 291,000 passengers, but planes were diverted to other airports in Britain and across Europe, while many long-haul flights returned to their point of departure.
Heathrow Chief Executive Thomas Woldbye said he expected the airport to be back “in full operation” on Saturday.
Asked who would pay for the disruption, he said there were “procedures in place,” adding “we don’t have liabilities in place for incidents like this.”
Restrictions on overnight flights were temporarily lifted by Britain’s Department of Transport to ease congestion, but British Airways chief executive Sean Doyle said the closure was set to have a “huge impact on all of our customers flying with us over the coming days.”
Virgin Atlantic said it expected to operate “a near full schedule” with limited cancelations on Saturday but that the situation remained dynamic and all flights would be kept under continuous review.
Airlines including JetBlue, American Airlines, Air Canada, Air India, Delta Air Lines, Qantas, United Airlines, British Airways and Virgin were diverted or returned to their origin airports in the wake of the closure, according to data from flight analytics firm Cirium.
Shares in many airlines fell on Friday.
Aviation experts said the last time European airports experienced disruption on such a large scale was the 2010 Icelandic volcanic ash cloud that grounded some 100,000 flights.
They warned that some passengers forced to land in Europe may have to stay in transit lounges if they lack the paperwork to leave the airport.
Prices at hotels around Heathrow jumped, with booking sites offering rooms for 500 pounds ($645), roughly five times the normal price levels.
Police said after an initial assessment, they were not treating the incident at the power substation as suspicious, although enquiries remained ongoing. London Fire Brigade said its investigations would focus on the electrical distribution equipment.
Heathrow and London’s other major airports have been hit by other outages in recent years, most recently by an automated gate failure and an air traffic system meltdown, both in 2023.


On World Water Day, PM calls for steps to preserve glaciers for Pakistan's secure future

On World Water Day, PM calls for steps to preserve glaciers for Pakistan's secure future
Updated 13 min 31 sec ago
Follow

On World Water Day, PM calls for steps to preserve glaciers for Pakistan's secure future

On World Water Day, PM calls for steps to preserve glaciers for Pakistan's secure future
  • Pakistan has around 13,000 glaciers, of which nearly 10,000 are receding and expected to cause significant water disruptions
  • PM Shehbaz Sharif says Pakistan's wetlands are disappearing three times faster than its forests and demand immediate action

ISLAMABAD: Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif has urged Pakistanis to take steps to preserve water resources, including glaciers, for a water-secure future of the country, his office said on Saturday, on the World Water Day.
The World Water Day is an annual United Nations (UN) observance held on March 22 each year that highlights the importance of freshwater. The day is used to advocate for sustainable management of freshwater resources across the globe.
In his message, Sharif said the day, being observed under the theme of “Glacier Preservation” this year, reminds them of the critical role glaciers play in sustaining the planet’s freshwater supplies and of the grave challenges in protecting this essential resource.
"Nearly half of the global population experiences water scarcity for at least part of the year. Billions remain without access to clean drinking water, while water pollution continues to rise at alarming levels. Our wetlands are disappearing three times faster than our forests. This is no longer a distant threat. It is a global crisis that demands immediate and collective action," Sharif was quoted as saying by his office.
"On this World Water Day, let us reaffirm our resolve to preserve our glaciers, protect our water resources, and work together for a resilient, water-secure future—for our people, our region, and our planet."
There are a total of 13,000 glaciers in Pakistan and nearly 10,000 of them are receding and expected to cause significant water disruptions, according to Pakistani authorities.
The melting of these glaciers at a fast pace and heavy untimely rains due to climate change put the South Asian country at risk of frequent floods, while at the same time, droughts pose an equally serious threat, with nearly 80 percent of Pakistan's land categorized as arid or semi-arid and 30 percent of population directly affected by drought-like conditions.
Melting glaciers contribute to rising sea levels, another cause of coastal erosion. The sea level at Karachi rose almost 8 inches (almost 20 centimeters) between 1916 and 2016, according to data from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. It’s projected to rise another half-inch (about 1.3 centimeters) by 2040.
In areas near the southwestern coastal city of Gwadar, like Pishukan and Ganz, waves have swallowed up mosques, schools, and settlements. There are gashes in the cliffs at the popular picnic spot of Sunset Park and rocks have cascaded onto the shore, while beaches run flat for dozens of kilometers because no structures remain on it.
"Pakistan is among the ten countries most vulnerable to climate change. Our average temperatures are projected to rise faster than the global average," Sharif said.
"Over three-quarters of our water resources originate outside our borders. That is why Pakistan attaches great importance to transboundary water cooperation."
He said his government was working to mitigate climate-induced flood risks and reduce drought impacts through ecosystem-based adaptation, and implementing 25 priority interventions from promoting nature-based agriculture and restoring the Indus delta to curbing industrial pollution and investing in green infrastructure.


Israel warns it will respond to rockets fired from Lebanon

Israel warns it will respond to rockets fired from Lebanon
Updated 15 min 16 sec ago
Follow

Israel warns it will respond to rockets fired from Lebanon

Israel warns it will respond to rockets fired from Lebanon
  • The Israeli military said three rockets had entered Israeli territory but were intercepted

Jerusalem: Israeli Defense Minister Israel Katz warned the military would hit back after intercepting three rockets fired from Lebanon into northern Israel on Saturday.
“We cannot allow fire from Lebanon on Galilee communities,” Katz said in a statement. “The Lebanese government is responsible for attacks from its territory. I have ordered the military to respond accordingly.”
Air raid sirens sounded at 7:30 am in Metula, an Israeli town near the Lebanese border.
The Israeli military later said three rockets had entered Israeli territory but were intercepted.
“We promised security to Galilee communities, and that is exactly what will happen,” Katz said. “Metula’s fate is the same as Beirut’s.”
The official National News Agency in Lebanon said Israeli warplanes flew over eastern areas of southern Lebanon and that interceptor missiles exploded.
NNA said Israeli ground troops were strafing the Hamames hills with automatic weapon fire.
It also reported Israeli artillery fire on the Nabatieh district in the south and the town of Khiam, which was hit by “three shells (fired by) Merkava tanks.”
The military also fired automatic weapons at the border villages of Hula, Markaba and Kfar Kila.
A November 27 truce largely halted more than a year of fighting between Iran-backed Hezbollah and Israel, including two months of full-blown war during which Israel sent in ground troops.


Pakistan urges halt in Israeli strikes on Gaza for success of Saudi-backed conference on two-state solution

Pakistan urges halt in Israeli strikes on Gaza for success of Saudi-backed conference on two-state solution
Updated 19 min 38 sec ago
Follow

Pakistan urges halt in Israeli strikes on Gaza for success of Saudi-backed conference on two-state solution

Pakistan urges halt in Israeli strikes on Gaza for success of Saudi-backed conference on two-state solution
  • Development comes after French President Emmanuel Macron said he spoke with Saudi Arabia’s Crown Prince and they will co-chair a conference on the two-state solution
  • Pakistan does not recognize Israel and has consistently called for an independent Palestinian state based on ‘internationally agreed parameters’ and pre-1967 borders

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan urges the world to halt Israeli strikes on Gaza for the success of a conference in June on the two-state solution to the Palestine issue, Pakistan’s permanent mission to the United Nations (UN) said on Saturday.
The statement came days after French President Emmanuel Macron said he spoke with Saudi Arabia’s Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman and the two leaders condemned the resumption of Israeli strikes on Gaza. Macron said they will co-chair a conference on a two-state solution, aimed at “helping revive a political perspective for both Israelis and Palestinians.”
The Israeli military on Wednesday resumed ground operations in central and southern Gaza, as a second day of airstrikes killed at least 48 Palestinians, according to health authorities. The renewed ground operations came a day after more than 400 Palestinians were killed in airstrikes in one of the deadliest episodes since the beginning of the conflict in October 2023, shattering a ceasefire that has largely held since January.
“If we can halt Israel’s military campaign, sustain a ceasefire and end the humanitarian crisis, it would create conditions conducive to the success of the endeavor for a two-State solution at the Conference, co-chaired by Saudi Arabia and France, next June,” the Pakistani mission quoted the country’s permanent representative, Munir Akram, as saying at the UN.
“This is an outcome that should be desired by the world and should enjoy consensus within the Security Council.”
Palestinian territory – encompassing the Gaza Strip and West Bank, including East Jerusalem – has been occupied by Israel since 1967. Pakistan does not recognize Israel and has consistently called for an independent Palestinian state based on “internationally agreed parameters” and pre-1967 borders.
“The Security Council, and the world community, cannot sit back and watch this on-going ethnic cleansing,” Akram was quoted as saying. “A failure to halt this brutal war will unleash the worst instinct of powerful and predatory states, shred the principles of the UN Charter, designed to prevent aggression and the scourge of war.”
Israel’s war on Gaza, which began after the Oct. 7, 2023 attacks by Hamas, has killed more than 48,000 Palestinians, most of them women and children, and displaced almost all of Gaza’s 2 million population by laying waste to swathes of neighborhoods, schools and hospitals.


At least nine injured as police, ethnic Baloch protesters clash in Pakistan’s southwest

At least nine injured as police, ethnic Baloch protesters clash in Pakistan’s southwest
Updated 22 March 2025
Follow

At least nine injured as police, ethnic Baloch protesters clash in Pakistan’s southwest

At least nine injured as police, ethnic Baloch protesters clash in Pakistan’s southwest
  • The clashes erupted during a protest by the Baloch Yakjehti Committee rights group over the arrest of three of its key members by authorities this week
  • Balochistan, Pakistan’s largest province by land, has been the site of an insurgency for decades and has witnessed a surge in violence in recent months

QUETTA: At least nine people, including policemen, were injured after clashes broke out between police and protesters from an ethnic Baloch rights group, the Baloch Yakjehti Committee, late Friday night in the southwestern Pakistani city of Quetta, officials said.
The BYC accused law enforcement agencies of forcibly arresting its three central committee members on Wednesday and called for a protest on Sariab Road in Quetta, the capital of Balochistan province which has recent witnessed a spike in separatist attacks.
The call for protest followed a clash between protesters and the police after people attempted to take away bodies of deceased militants who were killed after the Jaffar Express train hijacking last week, according to authorities. The provincial government lodged a police case against the protesters who stormed the mortuary at Civil Hospital Quetta and booked 12 protesters on Thursday.
Last week, militants from the Baloch Liberation Army (BLA) separatist group hijacked the Peshawar-bound Jaffar Express passenger train in the rugged, mountainous Bolan region, with more than 400 passengers onboard. The hours-long siege ended after Pakistan launched an operation and killed 33 militants. The deadliest train assault resulted in the killing of over 30 Pakistani security personnel and civilians.
“The Baloch Yakjehti Committee blocked highways in Quetta and the police took legal action against the protesters who were blocking the roads,” Shahid Rind, a spokesman for the Balochistan government, said on Friday.
“The protesters pelted stones at police and tortured policemen, injuring several cops and civilians.”
The BYC was staging a sit-in on Sariab Road with bodies of three protesters, which it alleged were killed by gunfire from the authorities.
Rind said the government was ascertaining whose bodies BYC placed in their protest: “It is impossible to know the causes of death of the bodies unless the bodies were brought to the hospital for medico-legal procedure.”
Dr. Arbab Kamran Kasi, head of Trauma Center Quetta told Arab News, they had received nine injured persons, including policemen.
“Six injured with minor wounds were discharged, two are being treated and one was referred to the Combined Military Hospital,” he shared.
Dr. Mahrang Baloch, a veteran human rights activist who heads the BYC, accused police of killing three protesters by shooting at a peaceful rally in Quetta.
“We called a peaceful sit-in today on the Sariab Road in Quetta but the police attacked our protesters,” she told Arab News. “Now we have camped at Sariab Road with the bodies of three slain protesters and we won’t end the protest until justice has been provided to our slain workers.”
The office of the Quetta commissioner denied reports of firing by authorities.
“No shelling was carried out by the administration during the BYC protest. No firearms or rubber bullets were used,” it said in a statement. “Only water cannons (non-lethal and safe method) were used to disperse the crowd.”
It said the administration respects the right to peaceful protest, however, lawlessness and attacks on state institutions cannot be permitted.
Amnesty International, a global human rights watchdog, voiced alarm over the reports of deaths of three protesters and nearly a dozen injuries following live ammunition fired by authorities against the protesters in Quetta, describing it as “a shocking indictment of the Pakistani authorities’ utter disregard for human life.”
“In blatant violation of the right to protest, the authorities conducted mass arrests and fired tear gas before resorting to unlawful use of lethal weapons against the unarmed protesters. Mobile networks in the city remain suspended, hindering free flow of information,” it said on X.
“Amnesty International urges the Pakistani authorities to immediately stop the reckless crackdown against the peaceful protesters and guarantee the right to freedom of peaceful assembly and expression, in line with Pakistan’s international human rights obligations.”
Balochistan is Pakistan’s largest province by land but its most backward by almost all economic and social indicators. For decades it has been plagued by a low-level insurgency by militants fighting for a greater share of the province’s wealth.
Separatist militants, such as the Baloch Liberation Army (BLA) accuse the central government of denying locals a share of Balochistan’s mineral resources. The federal government and the military strongly deny these accusations, and say they have launched several projects in the province to support its development.
Violence by Baloch separatist factions, primarily the BLA, killed about 300 people last year, according to official statistics, marking an escalation in the decades-long conflict.