Palestinians still resisting 40 years on from Sabra and Shatila
Sept. 16 marks the 40th anniversary of the Sabra and Shatila massacre, the killing of about 3,000 Palestinians by Lebanon’s Phalangist militias operating under the command of the Israeli army.
Four decades have passed, yet no measure of justice has been received by the survivors of the massacre. Many of them have died and others are aging while they still carry the scars of physical and psychological wounds. They hope that, perhaps, within their lifetime, they will see their executioners put behind bars.
However, many of the Israeli and Phalange commanders who ordered the invasion of Lebanon or orchestrated or carried out the heinous massacres in the two Palestinian refugee camps in 1982 have already died. Ariel Sharon, who was implicated by the official Israeli Kahan Commission a year later for his “indirect responsibility” for the grisly mass killing and rapes, later became Israel’s prime minister.
Even prior to the Sabra and Shatila massacre, Sharon’s name was affiliated with mass murders and large-scale destruction. It was in the so-called Operation Shoshana, in the Palestinian West Bank village of Qibya in 1953, that Sharon earned his reputation. Following the Israeli occupation of Gaza in 1967, the Israeli general became known as “The Bulldozer” and, following Sabra and Shatila, “The Butcher.”
The Israeli prime minister at the time, Menachim Begin, also died having exhibited no remorse for the deaths of more than 17,000 Lebanese, Palestinians and Syrians in the 1982 invasion of Lebanon. His nonchalant response to the killings in the West Beirut refugee camps epitomizes Israel’s attitude toward all the mass killings and massacres carried out against Palestinians in the last 75 years. “Goyim kill goyim, and they blame the Jews,” he said.
Testimonies from those who arrived at the refugee camps after the days of slaughter depict a reality that requires deep reflection, not only among Palestinians, Arabs and especially Israelis, but humanity as a whole.
The late American journalist Janet Lee Stevens described what she witnessed: “I saw dead women in their houses with their skirts up to their waists and their legs spread apart; dozens of young men shot after being lined up against an alley wall; children with their throats slit, a pregnant woman with her stomach chopped open, her eyes still wide open, her blackened face silently screaming in horror; countless babies and toddlers who had been stabbed or ripped apart and who had been thrown into garbage piles.”
The massacre is not simply a dark chapter in a bygone era, but is an ongoing moral crisis that continues to define Israel’s relationship with Palestinians.
At the time of the massacre, Dr. Swee Chai Ang had just arrived in Lebanon as a volunteer surgeon, stationed at the Red Crescent Society in the Gaza Hospital in Sabra and Shatila. Her book, “From Beirut to Jerusalem: A Woman Surgeon with the Palestinians,” remains one of the most critical volumes on the subject.
In a recent article, she wrote that, following the release of photographs of the “heaps of dead bodies in the camp alleys,” a worldwide outrage followed, but it was all short-lived. “The victims’ families and survivors were soon left alone to plod on with their lives and to relive the memory of that double tragedy of the massacre, and the preceding 10 weeks of intensive land, air and sea bombardment and blockade of Beirut during the invasion,” she wrote.
The Lebanese and Palestinian losses in the Israeli war were devastating in terms of numbers. However, the war also changed Lebanon forever and, following the forced exile of thousands of Palestinian men, along with the entire Palestinian Liberation Organization leadership, the Palestinian communities in Lebanon were left politically vulnerable, socially disadvantaged and economically isolated.
The story of Sabra and Shatila is not simply a dark chapter in a bygone era, but is an ongoing moral crisis that continues to define Israel’s relationship with Palestinians, to highlight the demographic and political trap in which numerous Palestinian communities in the Middle East live, and to accentuate the hypocrisy of the Western-dominated international community. The latter seems to care for some victims, but not others.
In the case of the Palestinians, the victims are often depicted by Western governments and media as the aggressors. Even during that horrific Israeli war on Lebanon 40 years ago, some Western leaders repeated the tired mantra: “Israel has the right to defend itself.” It is this unwavering support of Israel that has made the Israeli occupation, apartheid and siege of the West Bank and Gaza politically possible and financially sustainable — in fact, profitable.
Would Israel have been able to invade and massacre at will if it were not for US-Western military, financial and political backing? The answer is no. Those who are in doubt about such a conclusion need only consider the attempt, in 2002, by the survivors of the Lebanon refugee camps massacre to hold Sharon accountable. They took their case to Belgium, taking advantage of a Belgian law that allowed for the prosecution of alleged international war criminals. After much haggling, many delays and intense pressure from the US government, the Belgian court eventually dropped the case altogether. Ultimately, Brussels changed its own laws to ensure that such a diplomatic crisis with Washington and Tel Aviv would not be repeated.
For Palestinians, however, the case will never be dropped. In her essay, “Avenging Sabra and Shatila,” Kifah Sobhi Afifi described the joint Phalangist-Israeli attack on her refugee camp when she was only 12 years old. “So we ran, trying to stay as close to the walls of the camp as possible,” she wrote. “That is when I saw the piles of the dead bodies all around. Children, women and men, mutilated or groaning in pain as they were dying. Bullets were flying everywhere. People were falling all around me. I saw a father using his body to protect his children but they were all shot and killed anyway.”
Afifi has lost several members of her family. Years later, she joined a Palestinian resistance group and, following a raid at the Lebanon-Israel border, was arrested and tortured in Israel.
Though Israeli massacres are meant to bring an end to Palestinian resistance, instead they unwittingly fuel it. While Israel continues to act with impunity, Palestinians continue to resist. This is not just the lesson of Sabra and Shatila, but also the bigger lesson of the Israeli occupation of Palestine.
- Ramzy Baroud has been writing about the Middle East for more than 20 years. He is an internationally syndicated columnist, a media consultant, an author of several books, and the founder of PalestineChronicle.com. Twitter: @RamzyBaroud