Give Kejriwal and company a chance

Let's take the extremely cynical prediction of many commentators that the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) and its top leaders are going to fail. Their criticism basically revolves round a few specious arguments that they are inexperienced, they have a skewed vision of the future and that they promise too much.
Inexperience: When Manmohan Singh or Narendra Modi assumes office for the first time, few raise this question. Rahul Gandhi as a prime ministerial candidate is not even doubted. And what is their track record? Singh has presided over the most scam-ridden government in independent India. Modi in no way can absolve himself of the responsibility of anti-Muslim carnage. Questions about their competence or experience are not raised when Lalu Prasad or Mamata Banerjee, Beni Prasad or Sushil Shinde made a union minister. Take Shiela Dikshit. Under her watch, Commonwealth Games’ organization raised a public stink, women continued to feel insecure as governance evaporated. So much for experience!
Vision: Does Congress or the BJP have a vision? Their manifestoes are nothing but platitudes, sloganeering and empty promises. Under Congress and BJP, though relatively briefly, rulers have siphoned off public money. Citizenry has remained outside agenda setting. Crony capitalism has prospered and the majority of Indians have got increasingly marginalized.
Promising too much: Take any of the manifestoes of the Congress or the BJP. They promise the moon before every election, but can’t enact even a lame Lokpal (an anti-graft bill) for 40 years. Let’s not even mention other grandiose promises like removing poverty in five years.
Why, then, a different and exacting standard for the AAP or its leaders even before they started? We don’t need experts to tell us that a sense of doom and frustration had descended on Indians who do backbreaking struggle to make two ends meet. In the name of governance under Congress and BJP, and even the Left parties, ruling party apparatchiks have bossed over people and cornered privileges and obstreperous bureaucrats have bullied citizenry.
Contrast all that to AAP’s record thus far. It has not yet made any pompous claims, other than working toward a truly participatory democracy. On the contrary, it has kept its promises confined to common concerns like easy availability of power and water. Its top leaders shine in probity compared to the mostly tainted Congress and BJP leaders.
AAP has also stood apart with its views and practices, on three major features of a thriving democracy.
Transparency: No other party in India has maintained transparency about its working, fund collection and internal decision making the way AAP has shown thus far. Despite the calumny that AAP faced during Delhi’s election campaign, it remained the most open party, its source of funds regularly uploaded on its website. In a first, the party actually asked people not to donate any further when its collection reached the Rs2-billion mark. Can any other party claim this feat? We have no clue of who funds the BJP, the Congress and other political parties, not to talk about how much.
Accountability: Instead of defending any party member leader, AAP promptly set up inquiry committees when vested interests tried to slander Shazia Ilmi or Kumar Viswas when they were accused of favoring moneymaking deals. The swift inquiry found out that a blackmailer, possibly funded by one of the panicky major parties, tried to entrap the two. In similar situations, Congress and BJP would first close ranks and then defend the accused.
Governance: In a commendable departure, AAP ministers shunned the symbols of power and privilege — the red beacon lights, security cordons and sprawling bungalows — power trappings that have kept the elected representatives inaccessible to common people. For most politicians, politics is a gateway to power to grab money, exert influence and stand apart to be counted among the privileged. All this has made a mockery of our democracy. AAP leaders, in contrast, didn’t rush to power.
In another first, they went back to the people in improvised opinion polls. Only after about one million positive responses came, the AAP offered to assume power. In Congress, such decisions are taken by a mother, son and daughter trio and, in the BJP, often a triad, and in other parties, just one self-serving head.
The AAP has made a remarkably good start. Even if the party fails to hold on to power in Delhi, it would have irrevocably altered Indian political discourse, creating much welcome benchmarks in politics. Would that still be a failure? Surely not.
n Courtesy: Asian Lite